Micro 2 Final Exam, Moed B (March 2025) · Dr. Boaz Zik · worked-solution

Production Economy, Price Ceiling & True-False (2025 Moed B)

Production Economy, Price Ceiling & True-False (2025 Moed B)

Part of: Micro-Economics II Micro 2 Final Exam, Moed B (March 2025), Micro-Economics II, Dr. Boaz Zik. 3 hours, calculator only. Part 1 (10 true/false, 5 points each = 50 points), Question 2 (25 points), Question 3 (25 points). Builds on: Lec_04-Theory of the Firm, Partial & General Equilibrium, Lec_05-Production Economy & Externalities Practice: PS_01-Profit Maximisation & Properties of the Profit Function, PS_03-Cost Minimisation & Properties of the Cost Function, PS_04-Partial Equilibrium, Welfare & Price Ceilings, PS_05-Pareto Efficiency, Dominance & Social Welfare, PS_06-Exchange Equilibrium, Walrasian Prices & the Social Planner, PS_08-Production Economy, Efficiency Locus & Input Allocation

Source

The question paper is an image-only scan, so the question text below was transcribed from the scan by eye (a few handwritten marks on the scan are ignored). Part 1 and Q3 follow the official solutions. Question 2 has no official solution anywhere, so its text is transcribed and every part is marked as unsolved.

Question 2 is unsolved

No official solution exists for Q2 in the course materials. It is deliberately not solved here. See PS_08-Production Economy, Efficiency Locus & Input Allocation and Lec_05-Production Economy & Externalities for the method.

What this paper tests

Question Core idea Where it is taught
Part 1, (1) to (3) Cost minimisation and the optimal profit function: Perfect Substitutes-type corner, Homogeneity of Degree 1, only the price ratio matters PS_01-Profit Maximisation & Properties of the Profit Function, PS_03-Cost Minimisation & Properties of the Cost Function
Part 1, (4) to (5) Partial Equilibrium: a subsidy financed by a lump-sum tax vs a Price Ceiling-type price floor (minimum price) PS_04-Partial Equilibrium, Welfare & Price Ceilings
Part 1, (6) to (7) Exchange Economy: endowment on the Contract Curve, what an equilibrium price change can and cannot do PS_06-Exchange Equilibrium, Walrasian Prices & the Social Planner
Part 1, (8) to (9) Production Economy: scaling the resources, PPF and the Efficiency Locus PS_08-Production Economy, Efficiency Locus & Input Allocation
Part 1, (10) Pareto Efficiency and the social planner PS_05-Pareto Efficiency, Dominance & Social Welfare
Q2 Production economy with Cobb-Douglas firms (no official solution) Lec_05-Production Economy & Externalities
Q3 Quasilinear Utility demand, Cobb-Douglas supply, maximal price, comparative statics PS_04-Partial Equilibrium, Welfare & Price Ceilings
Intuition: the one move behind each block
  • Part 1: for each statement ask "what is the object, and what does it depend on?" (a price ratio, a homogeneous function, an aggregate endowment).
  • Q3: with a binding maximal price the short side decides quantity. Supply is the short side, so quantity solves MC=pˉMC = \bar p, and the demand curve only enters through consumer surplus.

Part 1 — True or false (50 points)

For each statement, state if it is true or false and provide a written argument for your answer (an answer without an argument will be marked zero).

(1) Cost after a rise in pkp_k (5 points)

Question. Consider a firm with production function f(l,k)=l+kf(l,k) = \sqrt{l} + k. Suppose the price of kk, pkp_k, increases while plp_l remains constant. Following this change, the cost of producing any quantity qq strictly increases. True/False.

Answer: False

For small enough quantities the firm would choose to produce only with labour, both before and after the change in pkp_k. For these quantities the cost of production remains the same.

Why. The statement says "any quantity", so one counterexample is enough. A rise in pkp_k can only hurt through the capital the firm uses. If the firm uses no capital at qq, the rise changes nothing.

Intuition (mine, consistent with the official argument)

The marginal product of labour, 12l\frac{1}{2\sqrt{l}}, is huge when ll is small, while the marginal product of capital is constant at 1. So at small qq labour is the better buy per dollar even at the old pkp_k, and the firm is at the labour corner (Corner Solution). Raising pkp_k makes capital even less attractive. At large qq the firm does use capital and cost does rise, which is why the statement fails only because of the word "any".

(2) Wage and product price rise together (5 points)

Question. A firm produces XX using only labour, with diminishing marginal productivity: f(l)f(l) with ff strictly concave. If both the wage ww and the product price pxp_x increase by the same proportion, then the firm's optimal profit remains unchanged. True/False.

Answer: False

The firm's optimal profit increases in the same proportion as pxp_x and ww.

Why. The firm solves max⁡l  pxf(l)−wl\max_l\; p_x f(l) - w l. Scaling (px,w)(p_x, w) by tt scales the whole objective by tt, so the optimal ll is unchanged but the profit is tt times larger. This is Homogeneity of Degree 1 of the Optimal Profit Function: Π∗(tpx,tw)=t Π∗(px,w)\Pi^*(t p_x, t w) = t\,\Pi^*(p_x, w). Only relative prices change the firm's decision; the level of profit scales with them.

(3) Both input prices rise together (5 points)

Question. A firm has f(l,k)=lαk1−αf(l,k) = l^{\alpha}k^{1-\alpha}. If both plp_l and pkp_k increase by the same proportion, then the firm's optimal input bundle for producing a given quantity qq remains unchanged. True/False.

Answer: True

The cost-minimising bundle for qq depends only on the input price ratio pkpl\frac{p_k}{p_l}, and this ratio does not change when both prices rise by the same proportion.

Why. The tangency condition Tangency Condition is RTS=plpkRTS = \frac{p_l}{p_k}, and with Cobb-Douglas RTS=α1−α⋅klRTS = \frac{\alpha}{1-\alpha}\cdot\frac{k}{l}. Together with f(l,k)=qf(l,k)=q this pins down (l,k)(l,k) using the ratio alone. The cost rises by the same proportion, but the bundle does not. See Cost Minimisation and Conditional Input Demand.

(4) Subsidy financed by a lump-sum tax (5 points)

Question. In a partial equilibrium model the government subsidises the price for consumers. To finance the subsidy, the government imposes a direct (lump-sum) tax on consumers. As a result, consumer surplus decreases compared to the scenario with no intervention. True/False.

Answer: True

If we ignore the financing, both consumer surplus and firm surplus increase. When we account for financing, overall welfare decreases. Since the consumers pay for the subsidy, consumer surplus decreases.

Why. The subsidy pushes the quantity above the efficient level, creating a Deadweight Loss. The firm gains from the subsidy and the consumer gains from the lower price, but the consumer also pays the entire bill through the lump-sum tax. Total welfare is the sum of the surpluses (the tax is a transfer from consumers to the government that is paid back to firms and consumers through the subsidy). Welfare falls by the deadweight loss, and the firm is better off, so the consumer must be worse off than with no intervention.

Intuition (mine)

The consumer is paying the firm to sell extra units that the consumer values at less than they cost to produce. The firm is happy to be paid; the consumer carries both the transfer and the waste.

(5) Minimum price equal to the subsidised price (5 points)

Question. The government does not implement a subsidy but instead sets a minimum price equal to the price under the subsidy policy of (4). Under this policy, the firm's surplus remains the same as it was following the subsidy policy in (4). True/False.

Answer: False

When the minimum price equals the subsidy price (and is above the equilibrium price), consumers demand less. The firm therefore sells a smaller quantity at the same price per unit, so its profit decreases relative to the subsidy policy of (4).

Why. Under a minimum price above equilibrium, the market is on the demand curve (the short side), so quantity is whatever consumers want at that price. Under the subsidy the quantity is larger (consumers face a lower effective price). Same unit price, fewer units sold, and units beyond the new quantity carried positive firm surplus, so the firm's surplus falls.

(6) Endowment on the contract curve (5 points)

Question. In an exchange economy where the initial endowment allocation lies on the contract curve, agents do not benefit from trade. True/False.

Answer: True

If the endowment is on the contract curve, the equilibrium allocation equals the endowment. Agents therefore do not benefit from trade.

Why. On the Contract Curve the allocation is already Pareto efficient, so no trade can make someone better off without hurting the other. The Walrasian equilibrium is individually rational and efficient, so it must be the endowment itself. See Walrasian Equilibrium and Core.

(7) A higher equilibrium pxp_x (5 points)

Question. In an exchange economy a change raises the equilibrium price pxp_x relative to its previous level. In the new equilibrium, both agents consume less of good XX. True/False.

Answer: False

In an exchange-economy equilibrium the agents consume the overall endowment. So total consumption of XX is the same under any equilibrium. It is impossible for both agents to consume less.

Why. Market clearing gives x1+x2=ωx1+ωx2x_1 + x_2 = \omega_{x1} + \omega_{x2}, a fixed number. A price change can shift XX from one agent to the other, but cannot lower both. A rise in pxp_x can at most move XX between the two agents.

(8) Doubling the input endowments (5 points)

Question. In a production economy the representative consumer has U(x,y)=xαy1−αU(x,y) = x^{\alpha}y^{1-\alpha}. The firms have f1(l1,k1)=l1ak11−af_1(l_1,k_1) = l_1^{a}k_1^{1-a} and f2(l2,k2)=l2ak21−af_2(l_2,k_2) = l_2^{a}k_2^{1-a}, with k1+k2=100k_1+k_2 = 100 and l1+l2=100l_1+l_2 = 100. The input endowments change to k1+k2=200k_1+k_2 = 200 and l1+l2=200l_1+l_2 = 200. In the new equilibrium, the quantities of both XX and YY are twice their previous equilibrium levels. True/False.

Answer: True

If k1+k2=Ak_1+k_2 = A and l1+l2=Al_1+l_2 = A, the optimal consumption of XX and YY is proportional to AA. It is the same as the Cobb-Douglas consumer problem with price ratio 1 and income AA. Since the resource constraints doubled, so do the optimal quantities.

Why. Both firms are constant-returns Cobb-Douglas with the same technology, so the PPF is the line x+y=Ax + y = A when kk and ll both equal AA (the official solution treats the price ratio as 1). The consumer then spends the share α\alpha of income AA on XX and 1−α1-\alpha on YY: x∗=αAx^* = \alpha A and y∗=(1−α)Ay^* = (1-\alpha)A. Doubling AA doubles both. See Production Economy and PS_08-Production Economy, Efficiency Locus & Input Allocation.

(9) A point on the PPF and equal RTS (5 points)

Question. In a production economy, assume (x0,y0)(x_0, y_0) lies on the production possibility frontier. There exist two points (l1,k1)(l_1,k_1) on the isoquant of x0x_0 and (l2,k2)(l_2,k_2) on the isoquant of y0y_0, such that RTS1(l1,k1)=RTS2(l2,k2)RTS_1(l_1,k_1) = RTS_2(l_2,k_2). True/False.

Answer: True

If (x0,y0)(x_0,y_0) is on the PPF there is an allocation of inputs ((l1,k1),(l2,k2))((l_1,k_1),(l_2,k_2)) along the efficiency locus that produces this output. That allocation has (l1,k1)(l_1,k_1) on the isoquant of x0x_0 and (l2,k2)(l_2,k_2) on the isoquant of y0y_0, and satisfies RTS1=RTS2RTS_1 = RTS_2.

Why. The PPF is built from the Efficiency Locus, where the two firms' isoquants are tangent (equal RTS). A point is on the PPF only if it is produced efficiently, which means equal RTS across firms.

(10) A non-Pareto-efficient allocation and the planner (5 points)

Question. If allocation AA is not Pareto efficient, then no central benevolent designer would select it. True/False.

Answer: True

A benevolent designer's utility must increase in the utilities of the agents. Since AA is not Pareto efficient, there is another allocation BB giving higher utility to all agents. Any benevolent designer prefers BB to AA, so no such designer would select AA.

Why. A planner's objective is increasing in each agent's utility (Social Welfare). A Pareto-dominating allocation raises every argument, so it raises the objective. See PS_05-Pareto Efficiency, Dominance & Social Welfare.


Q2 — Production economy (25 points)

No official solution

The question is transcribed from the scan. There is no official solution for Q2 in any of the course files, so no part is solved here.

Question. Consider the following production economy. The firms' production functions are f1(l1,k1)=2⋅(l11/3k12/3)f_1(l_1,k_1) = 2\cdot\left(l_1^{1/3}k_1^{2/3}\right) and f2(l2,k2)=2⋅(l21/3k22/3)f_2(l_2,k_2) = 2\cdot\left(l_2^{1/3}k_2^{2/3}\right). The representative consumer's utility function is U(x,y)=x1/3y2/3U(x,y) = x^{1/3}y^{2/3} and the resource constraints are k1+k2=50k_1+k_2 = 50 and l1+l2=50l_1+l_2 = 50.

a. Efficiency locus (5 points)

Find the efficiency locus in the economy.

No official solution

b. Production possibility frontier (5 points)

Find the production possibility frontier.

No official solution

c. Optimal allocation (5 points)

Find the optimal allocation in the economy.

No official solution

d. Equilibrium prices (5 points)

Find the equilibrium prices.

No official solution

e. Change in firm 2's technology (5 points)

Assume now that f1(l1,k1)=2⋅(l11/3k12/3)f_1(l_1,k_1) = 2\cdot\left(l_1^{1/3}k_1^{2/3}\right) and f2(l2,k2)=4⋅(l21/3k22/3)f_2(l_2,k_2) = 4\cdot\left(l_2^{1/3}k_2^{2/3}\right). What will happen to the ratio y∗x∗\frac{y^*}{x^*} in the optimal allocation of XX and YY? Explain your answer via graphical illustration.

No official solution

Q3 — Partial equilibrium with a maximal price (25 points)

Setup. A market with two products XX and YY, where YY represents money. Demand comes from a representative consumer with utility

U=A⋅x−x2+yU = A\cdot x - x^{2} + y

(income is high enough that there are no corner solutions). Supply is set by a representative firm with production function

f(k,l)=l1/4⋅k1/4f(k,l) = l^{1/4}\cdot k^{1/4}

and input prices plp_l and pkp_k.

a. Numerical case: A=180A = 180 and pl=pk=1p_l = p_k = 1

(i) The firm's cost function (4 points)

Answer

C(x)=2x2C(x) = 2x^{2}

Cost minimisation (Cost Minimisation): set RTS=plpkRTS = \frac{p_l}{p_k}. For this production function RTS=klRTS = \frac{k}{l}, and with equal prices this equals 1, so l=kl = k. Put this in the isoquant x=l1/4k1/4=l1/2x = l^{1/4}k^{1/4} = l^{1/2}, so

l(x)=x2,k(x)=x2,C(x)=l+k=2x2.l(x) = x^{2}, \qquad k(x) = x^{2}, \qquad C(x) = l + k = 2x^{2}.

(ii) Equilibrium price, quantity and surpluses (4 points)

Answer

x∗=30x^* = 30, p∗=120p^* = 120, consumer surplus =900= 900, firm surplus =1800= 1800, social welfare =2700= 2700.

The consumer maximises Ax−x2+yAx - x^2 + y subject to px+y=p x + y = income. Quasilinearity gives inverse demand p=A−2x=180−2xp = A - 2x = 180 - 2x (Quasilinear Utility). Marginal cost is C′(x)=4xC'(x) = 4x. Equilibrium solves

180−2x∗=4x∗  ⇒  x∗=30,p∗=4(30)=120.180 - 2x^{*} = 4x^{*} \;\Rightarrow\; x^{*} = 30, \qquad p^{*} = 4(30) = 120.

The surpluses are

CS=180x∗−(x∗)2−120x∗=5400−900−3600=900,CS = 180x^{*} - (x^{*})^{2} - 120x^{*} = 5400 - 900 - 3600 = 900,
FS=120x∗−2(x∗)2=3600−1800=1800,FS = 120x^{*} - 2(x^{*})^{2} = 3600 - 1800 = 1800,

and Social Welfare is 900+1800=2700900 + 1800 = 2700. See Consumer Surplus and Firm Surplus.

(iii) A maximal price of 80 (4 points)

Answer

Quantity =20= 20, consumer surplus =1600= 1600, firm surplus =800= 800, social welfare =2400= 2400.

Equilibrium Maximal price 80 Change
Quantity 30 20 falls
Consumer surplus 900 1600 rises
Firm surplus 1800 800 falls
Social welfare 2700 2400 falls

The maximal price 80 is below the equilibrium price 120, so it binds. At price 80 consumers want more than firms will supply, so supply is the short side and quantity solves C′(x)=80C'(x) = 80:

4x=80  ⇒  x=20.4x = 80 \;\Rightarrow\; x = 20.
CS=180(20)−202−80(20)=3600−400−1600=1600,CS = 180(20) - 20^{2} - 80(20) = 3600 - 400 - 1600 = 1600,
FS=80(20)−2(20)2=1600−800=800.FS = 80(20) - 2(20)^{2} = 1600 - 800 = 800.

Social welfare is 1600+800=24001600 + 800 = 2400, a Deadweight Loss of 300300 relative to 27002700.

PP07_q3_max_price_numerical

The maximal price caps the quantity at 20 where marginal cost meets the price cap. The grey triangle is the welfare lost relative to the equilibrium.

Explanation (official). Consumer surplus increases: the lower price more than compensates the consumer for the lower quantity. Firm surplus decreases: the firm sells fewer units and at a lower price. Social welfare decreases because the allocation no longer coincides with the equilibrium allocation.

Typos in the official solution

The official text says "The consumer surplus equal 80x−2x280x - 2x^2" and later "The consumer surplus decreased". Both slips should read firm surplus. The numbers (1600 and 800) are right: 180(20)−400−1600=1600180(20) - 400 - 1600 = 1600 and 80(20)−2(400)=80080(20) - 2(400) = 800.

Intuition

Welfare drops because some trades worth doing (units between 20 and 30, where willingness to pay exceeds marginal cost) no longer happen. The consumer wins on the units that do trade (price 80 instead of 120), the firm loses on them.

b. Demand rises under a binding maximal price (5 points)

Question. Consider the general market (not the numbers of (a)). The government sets a maximal price smaller than the equilibrium price. Now there is an increase in demand, captured by an increase in the parameter AA (same maximal price). What happens to firm surplus and consumer surplus compared with before the change? Give verbal and graphical explanations.

Answer

Firm surplus is unchanged. Consumer surplus increases.

An increase in AA shifts demand up, so the equilibrium price rises and the maximal price is still below it. The quantity is therefore still set where marginal cost equals the maximal price. Marginal cost does not depend on AA, so the quantity is unchanged. The firm sells the same quantity at the same price with the same cost, so

FS=p⋅x−C(x)FS = p\cdot x - C(x)

does not change. Consumer surplus is

CS=A⋅x−x2−p⋅x,CS = A\cdot x - x^{2} - p\cdot x,

and even though xx and pp do not change, AA rises, so CSCS rises.

c. Input prices fall under a binding maximal price (5 points)

Question. Same setup, but now the input prices plp_l and pkp_k decrease (same maximal price). What happens to firm surplus and consumer surplus?

Answer

Both consumer surplus and firm surplus increase.

A fall in input prices lowers marginal cost. Quantity is set where price equals marginal cost, so the quantity rises. The price stays equal to the maximal price. Consumer surplus rises because it increases in the quantity at a given price. Firm surplus also rises because marginal cost fell, so the firm earns more on every unit sold.

PP07_q3_max_price_shifts

Left: a demand shift (b) leaves the quantity at the unchanged supply point. Right: a fall in costs (c) moves that point to the right. Schematic, no numbers.

d. Why (b) and (c) differ (3 points)

Answer

In (b) a demand increase leaves the quantity unchanged because, under a binding maximal price, the quantity is set by supply, which did not change. Only the consumer benefits. In (c) a cost decrease raises the supply, so the quantity changes, and both the firm and the consumer benefit.

Intuition

A price cap makes the market supply-determined. Anything that shifts only demand is invisible to the firm and benefits consumers through the surplus formula. Anything that shifts supply changes the quantity actually traded, so it matters to both sides.


Recap

Item Verdict or answer One-line reason
(1) False Small qq: labour only, so cost does not change
(2) False Profit is homogeneous of degree 1, scales with the prices
(3) True Bundle depends only on pl/pkp_l/p_k
(4) True Consumer bears the lump-sum tax and the deadweight loss
(5) False A minimum price cuts quantity, firm sells less
(6) True Endowment on contract curve means no trade
(7) False Total XX fixed, one agent can only gain what the other loses
(8) True Doubling AA doubles x∗x^* and y∗y^* (Cobb-Douglas, price ratio 1)
(9) True PPF points are produced on the efficiency locus (equal RTS)
(10) True A Pareto-dominating allocation raises any planner's objective
Q2 No official solution Not solved
Q3(a)(i) C(x)=2x2C(x) = 2x^2 l=k=x2l = k = x^2
Q3(a)(ii) x∗=30x^*=30, p∗=120p^*=120, CS=900CS=900, FS=1800FS=1800, W=2700W=2700 180−2x=4x180-2x = 4x
Q3(a)(iii) x=20x=20, CS=1600CS=1600, FS=800FS=800, W=2400W=2400 4x=804x = 80
Q3(b) FSFS same, CSCS up Quantity set by unchanged supply
Q3(c) FSFS up, CSCS up Lower MCMC raises quantity
Q3(d) Different Only supply shifts move the quantity under a cap