Week 3

Rate Conversion, Effective Rates & EAC

Rate Conversion, Effective Rates & EAC

Part of: Financial Management Lesson 3 — Financial Management & Finance Key concepts: Effective Interest Rate, Stated Rate, Rate Conversion, Profitability Index, Equivalent Annual Cost


The core problem: rates only mean something with a frequency

"12% per year" is ambiguous until you know how often it compounds. 1% per month is not 12% per year, because the monthly interest itself earns interest. This lesson is about converting rates between frequencies correctly and using the right one in every formula.

Two different conversions — don't confuse them
  1. Effective-to-effective (true compounding): convert a real per-period rate to another period using (1+r)(1+r) powers. Used when you already have a genuine effective rate.
  2. Stated-to-effective (APR → EAR): a Stated Rate (APR) is quoted annually but applied mm times a year by simple division. Convert with the (1+rm)m(1+\frac{r}{m})^m formula.

1. Effective-rate conversions

If rr is the true effective rate over a period, the equivalent rate over a fraction/multiple of that period uses the geometric relationship — money compounds, it doesn't add:

(1+rannual)=(1+rperiod)m  ⟹  rperiod=(1+rannual)1/m−1\boxed{(1+r_{\text{annual}}) = (1+r_{\text{period}})^{m}}\;\Longrightarrow\; r_{\text{period}} = (1+r_{\text{annual}})^{1/m}-1
6% effective annual → shorter periods
Period mm r=(1.06)1/m−1r = (1.06)^{1/m}-1
Semi-annual 2 2.956%
Quarterly 4 1.467%
Monthly 12 0.4868%
Daily 365 0.01597%

Note these are below 6%/m6\%/m — because compounding the smaller rate mm times must land back at exactly 6%.

Common mistake

Do not divide an effective annual rate by 12 to get a monthly rate. 6%/12=0.5%6\%/12 = 0.5\% monthly compounds to (1.005)12−1=6.17%(1.005)^{12}-1 = 6.17\%, not 6%. Division only applies to stated rates (next section).


2. Stated (APR) vs Effective (EAR)

A loan quoted at "6% annual, compounded monthly" means the bank charges 6%/12=0.5%6\%/12 = 0.5\% per month. The true annual cost is:

reff,annual=(1+rstatedm)m−1\boxed{r_{\text{eff,annual}} = \left(1+\frac{r_{\text{stated}}}{m}\right)^{m}-1}

As compounding gets more frequent (m→∞m\to\infty) the EAR approaches the continuous limit:

reff=erstated−1r_{\text{eff}} = e^{r_{\text{stated}}}-1
Stated 6% under different frequencies
Compounded mm EAR
Annually 1 6.000%
Semi-annually 2 6.090%
Quarterly 4 6.136%
Monthly 12 6.168%
Daily 365 6.183%
Continuously ∞ 6.184%

Excel: EFFECT(stated, m) gives the EAR; NOMINAL(eff, m) reverses it.

L3_effective_vs_frequency

Why the curve flattens

Each extra compounding step adds interest-on-interest, but the marginal benefit shrinks — going annual→monthly adds 0.17%, but monthly→continuous adds only 0.016%. The effective rate is bounded above by the continuous case er−1e^{r}-1.


3. Profitability Index & capital rationing

When you can't fund every positive-NPV project (a budget constraint), rank by bang-for-buck, not by raw NPV.

PI=NPVInitial Investment(some texts use PVI; here PI=NPVI)\boxed{PI = \frac{NPV}{\text{Initial Investment}}}\quad\text{(some texts use } \tfrac{PV}{I}\text{; here } PI=\tfrac{NPV}{I}\text{)}
Decision procedure under a budget
  1. Compute PI for every project.
  2. Rank highest PI first.
  3. "Spend down" the budget greedily; the last project may be funded fractionally if it's divisible.

If projects were mutually exclusive instead, you'd simply pick the single highest-NPV project — PI is specifically for squeezing the most value out of a limited budget across several projects.


4. Equivalent Annual Cost / Annuity (EAC / EAV)

How do you compare projects (or machines) with different lifespans? Convert each one's NPV into the level annual cash flow it is equivalent to — then compare those annual figures on a like-for-like basis.

EAC=NPVAnnuity factor=NPV1r(1−(1+r)−n)\boxed{EAC = \frac{NPV}{\text{Annuity factor}} = \frac{NPV}{\frac{1}{r}\big(1-(1+r)^{-n}\big)}}

Equivalently, EAC=−PMT(r,n,NPV)EAC = -\texttt{PMT}(r, n, NPV) in Excel.

Renewable projects of unequal length

Project A: (−50,0,110)(-50, 0, 110) over 2 years, NPV =40.91= 40.91 at r=10%r=10\% → EACA=−PMT(10%,2,40.91)=$23.57/yrEAC_A = -\texttt{PMT}(10\%,2,40.91) = \$23.57/\text{yr}. Project B: −100-100 now, +322.11+322.11 in year 6, NPV =81.82= 81.82 → EACB=−PMT(10%,6,81.82)=$18.79/yrEAC_B = -\texttt{PMT}(10\%,6,81.82) = \$18.79/\text{yr}. Although B has the higher NPV, A delivers more per year (23.57>18.7923.57 > 18.79) — for an indefinitely repeatable project, A is better. Comparing raw NPVs of different-length projects would be apples-to-oranges.

When to reach for EAC

Use EAC whenever the alternatives repeat or have different horizons (machine replacement, lease vs buy, recurring projects). It annualises away the horizon difference.


Summary

Tool Formula Use when
Effective conversion (1+ra)1/m−1(1+r_a)^{1/m}-1 converting a true rate across periods
APR → EAR (1+rm)m−1(1+\frac{r}{m})^m-1 a stated rate applied mm×/year
Continuous limit er−1e^{r}-1 compounding "all the time"
Profitability index NPV/INPV/I budget constraint, divisible projects
Equivalent annual cost NPV÷NPV \div annuity factor different lifespans / repeating projects
The one trap to remember

Divide stated rates by mm; compound effective rates with powers. Mixing the two is the single most common error in this course.