HW3

  1. 1a

    Capital rationing with the profitability index. Six projects each have an initial investment and an NPV. Compute the profitability index PI=NPV/IPI = NPV/I of each project and rank them.

    Project Investment NPV
    A 500k 110k
    B 150k -7.5k
    C 350k 70k
    D 450k 81k
    E 200k 40k
    F 400k 20k
  2. 1b

    Does scaling a project down to 60% of its size change its profitability index?

  3. 1d

    You have a budget of $1,000,000 and projects are divisible. Allocate the budget by PI rank and find the total NPV.

  4. 1e

    Now suppose the projects cannot be split. Is following the PI ranking still guaranteed to maximise NPV?

  5. 2

    Equivalent Annual Cost. Two machines with different lifespans are compared at a discount rate of r=6%r = 6\%.

    Machine Cost Life
    A $10,000 5 years
    B $18,000 8 years

    Which machine should you choose?

  6. 3

    Equivalent Annual Value and replacement timing (r=16%r = 16\%). Four projects (J, K, L, M) with different lifespans are ranked by NPV and by equivalent annual value, EAV=NPV÷annuity factorEAV = NPV \div \text{annuity factor}. Do the two rankings agree?

  7. 3c

    When does a 15% cost cut to project M still beat J?

Related: Lesson_03-Rate Conversion, Effective Rates & EAC · Lesson_02-Perpetuities, NPV & IRR