Week 4 · Alon Cohen

The Monetary System

The Monetary System

Part of: Macro-Economics II | Key concepts: Money Supply, Money Multiplier, Fractional Reserve Banking, Monetary Base, Federal Reserve, Bank Capital, Leverage, Quantitative Easing


What This Chapter Is About

Chapter 4 answers two fundamental questions: what exactly is money, and how does the banking system determine how much of it exists in the economy? The punchline is that the banking system creates money — a $1 deposit can become $5 in total money supply through the multiplier process. Central banks try to control this, but households and banks both have a say too.

Where Chapter 4 fits

Chapter 3 showed how the real economy works in the long run. Chapter 4 introduces the monetary side — the quantity of money, who controls it, and how it interacts with prices (the full story of inflation follows in Chapter 5).


Money: Definition, Functions, and Types

Definition

Definition: Money

Money is the stock of assets that can be readily used to make transactions.

This sounds obvious but the key word is stock (not a flow) and readily used — an asset you'd have to sell first (like a bond) doesn't count.

Functions of Money

Money serves three distinct roles:

Function Meaning Example
Medium of exchange We use it to buy goods and services Paying for coffee
Store of value Transfers purchasing power through time Saving for next year
Unit of account Common yardstick for quoting prices "The car costs $20,000"
Intuition: Why all three?

Barter economies fail because of the double coincidence of wants problem — you need to find someone who wants what you have and has what you want. Money eliminates this. But to be useful, money also has to hold its value over time (otherwise people refuse it) and be universally understood as a measure.

Types of Money

Type Has Intrinsic Value? Examples
Commodity money ✅ Yes Gold coins, cigarettes in POW camps
Fiat money ❌ No Paper currency, bank reserves

Fiat money has value purely by government decree and social convention — it's "legal tender." Most modern economies run on fiat money.

What counts as money?
  • Currency ✅ — cash in your pocket
  • Demand deposits ✅ — cheque accounts (you can spend directly)
  • Checks ❌ — an instruction to move money, not money itself
  • Credit cards ❌ — a loan, not a store of assets
  • Bonds ❌ — must be sold first; not readily usable for transactions

The Money Supply and Its Measures

Key Definitions

Definition: Money Supply

The money supply is the quantity of money available in the economy, typically measured by M1 or M2.

Definition: Monetary Policy

Monetary policy is the central bank's control over the money supply — expanding or contracting it to influence prices, output, and employment.

M1 vs M2

Measure Components 2015 ($ bn) Aug 2025 ($ bn)
C (currency) Cash held by the public 1,279 2,404
M1 C + demand deposits + travelers' checks + other checkable deposits 2,988 18,899
M2 M1 + small time deposits + savings deposits + money market mutual funds + money market deposit accounts 11,846 22,195
M1 vs M2: Liquidity

M1 is the most liquid — assets you can spend immediately. M2 adds less-liquid assets that require notice or have restrictions (but can still be accessed fairly quickly). The dramatic jump in M1 from 2015 to 2025 partly reflects how the Fed categorised savings accounts after 2020.

Key definitions for money supply components:

  • Demand deposit — a standard bank account; funds can be withdrawn at any time without prior notice
  • Time deposit — an interest-bearing account where withdrawal requires advance notice (typically 30 days); a Certificate of Deposit (CD) is the classic example
  • Savings deposit — interest-bearing, with limits on the number of withdrawals per period; normally no chequebook
  • Money market fund — a mutual fund investing in low-risk, short-term assets; shares can be redeemed on any business day
  • Money market account — an interest-bearing bank account that allows check-writing, but usually requires a higher minimum balance

How Banks Create Money

The Basic Identity

M=C+DM = C + D

where CC = currency held by the public, DD = demand (checking) deposits.

Because MM includes DD, the banking system directly shapes the money supply. Understanding how requires working through three scenarios, starting from C=$1,000C = \$1{,}000, D=0D = 0, M=$1,000M = \$1{,}000.

Reserves: The Key Concept

Definition: Reserves

Reserves (RR) are the portion of deposits that banks have not lent out — physical cash held in the vault or on deposit at the central bank. Reserves are NOT included in currency (CC).

A simplified bank balance sheet:

Assets Liabilities
Reserves $200 Deposits $1,000
Loans $800

Scenario 1: No Banks

D=0,M=C=$1,000D = 0, \quad M = C = \$1{,}000

No banking system means no money creation — the money supply is just whatever cash exists.

Scenario 2: 100%-Reserve Banking

Every dollar deposited is held as a reserve. After depositing $1,000:

C=0,D=$1,000,R=$1,000,M=$1,000C = 0, \quad D = \$1{,}000, \quad R = \$1{,}000, \quad M = \$1{,}000
Lesson

100%-reserve banking does not change the money supply. Money just moves from currency to deposits — no new money is created.

Scenario 3: Fractional-Reserve Banking

Banks hold a reserve-deposit ratio of rr=0.20rr = 0.20 (20%) and lend the rest.

Bank Receives deposit Keeps (20%) Lends (80%)
Firstbank $1,000 $200 $800
Secondbank $800 $160 $640
Thirdbank $640 $128 $512
… … … …

Total money supply:

M=1rr×original deposit=10.20×$1,000=$5,000M = \frac{1}{rr} \times \text{original deposit} = \frac{1}{0.20} \times \$1{,}000 = \$5{,}000
Key Lesson

In a fractional-reserve banking system, banks create money through lending. But note: this creates new money, not new wealth — every new deposit to a borrower comes with an equal new debt.

Common Pitfall

Money creation ≠ wealth creation. The borrower gets $800 in purchasing power, but also has $800 in debt. The net addition to private sector wealth is zero. What changes is the liquidity of the economy — there is more money chasing goods.


Bank Capital, Leverage, and Capital Requirements

Modern banks have a more complex balance sheet than the simple reserves/deposits/loans picture above:

Assets $ Liabilities & Owners' Equity $
Reserves 200 Deposits 750
Loans 500 Debt (bonds issued) 200
Securities 300 Capital (owners' equity) 50
Total 1,000 Total 1,000

Bank Capital

Definition: Bank Capital

Bank capital is the owners' equity — what remains after subtracting all liabilities from assets. It is the bank's cushion against losses.

Bank capital=Assets−Liabilities\text{Bank capital} = \text{Assets} - \text{Liabilities}

In the example above: 1,000−950=$501{,}000 - 950 = \$50

Leverage

Definition: Leverage

Leverage is the use of borrowed money to supplement existing funds for investment.

Leverage ratio=AssetsCapital=$1,000$50=20\text{Leverage ratio} = \frac{\text{Assets}}{\text{Capital}} = \frac{\$1{,}000}{\$50} = 20

A leverage ratio of 20 means: for every $1 of the bank's own money, it controls $20 of assets. This magnifies both gains and losses.

Leverage Risk

If the bank's assets fall by just 5% (to $950), then: Capital=950−950=0\text{Capital} = 950 - 950 = 0 The bank is insolvent. A decline larger than 5% means depositors can't be repaid. With a leverage ratio of 20, even a small shock to asset values can wipe out equity entirely.

Capital Requirements

Capital Requirements

Regulators impose a minimum capital ratio to protect depositors. Banks holding riskier assets face stricter requirements, since riskier assets are more likely to fall in value.

The 2008–09 Financial Crisis vividly illustrated why this matters: losses on mortgage-backed securities eroded bank capital → banks cut lending → credit crunch worsened the recession → governments injected capital (bailouts) to stabilise the system.


A Formal Model of the Money Supply

Three Exogenous Variables

B=C+R⏟Monetary baserr=R/D⏟Reserve-deposit ratiocr=C/D⏟Currency-deposit ratio\underbrace{B = C + R}_{\text{Monetary base}} \qquad \underbrace{rr = R/D}_{\text{Reserve-deposit ratio}} \qquad \underbrace{cr = C/D}_{\text{Currency-deposit ratio}}
  • Monetary base (BB): controlled directly by the central bank
  • Reserve-deposit ratio (rrrr): depends on reserve requirements and bank discretion (excess reserves)
  • Currency-deposit ratio (crcr): depends on household preferences

Solving for the Money Supply

Starting from M=C+DM = C + D and using the definitions of crcr and rrrr:

M=m⋅B,wherem=1+crcr+rr\boxed{M = m \cdot B, \qquad \text{where} \quad m = \frac{1 + cr}{cr + rr}}

mm is the money multiplier.

The Money Multiplier

Definition: Money Multiplier

The money multiplier mm is the amount by which the money supply expands for each additional dollar of monetary base. If rr<1rr < 1, then m>1m > 1: the banking system amplifies base money into a larger money supply.

ΔM=m×ΔB\Delta M = m \times \Delta B
Worked Example

Suppose cr=0.5cr = 0.5 (households hold 50¢ in cash for every $1 in deposits) and rr=0.1rr = 0.1 (banks hold 10% reserves): m=1+0.50.5+0.1=1.50.6=2.5m = \frac{1 + 0.5}{0.5 + 0.1} = \frac{1.5}{0.6} = 2.5 So a $100 increase in the monetary base → $250 increase in money supply.

Intuition: What affects the multiplier?
  • ↑ crcr (households hold more cash): money spent in cash doesn't get re-deposited, so banks can create less additional money → mm falls → MM falls.
  • ↑ rrrr (banks hold more reserves): banks lend a smaller fraction of deposits → mm falls → MM falls.
  • Both crcr and rrrr are in the denominator of mm.

Instruments of Monetary Policy

The central bank controls the money supply through four main instruments:

Instrument What It Is To ↑ Money Supply Channel
Open Market Operations Fed buys/sells government bonds Buy bonds → pay with new dollars B↑B \uparrow
Discount Rate Interest rate the Fed charges banks for loans Lower discount rate → banks borrow more reserves B↑B \uparrow
Reserve Requirements Minimum rrrr mandated by regulators Lower reserve requirement rr↓⇒m↑rr \downarrow \Rightarrow m \uparrow
Interest on Reserves Interest the Fed pays banks on reserves held at Fed Pay lower interest → banks lend more rr↓⇒m↑rr \downarrow \Rightarrow m \uparrow

Open market operations are the Fed's preferred and most frequently used tool.

Why the Fed Can't Precisely Control MM

M=m⋅B=1+crcr+rr⋅BM = m \cdot B = \frac{1 + cr}{cr + rr} \cdot B The Fed directly controls BB, but both crcr (household preference) and rrrr (bank behaviour — excess reserves) are outside the Fed's direct control. If households hold more cash or banks pile up excess reserves, mm falls and MM may not rise even if BB rises.


Case Studies

Quantitative Easing (2008–2011)

QE in the 2008 Crisis
  • The Fed dramatically expanded the monetary base (BB tripled from August 2008 to August 2011).
  • But M1 grew only ~40% over the same period.
  • Why? The money multiplier collapsed: after mortgage losses, banks sharply increased excess reserves (rr↑rr \uparrow, m↓m \downarrow).
  • The Fed also broadened what it bought — not just short-term T-bills, but long-term government bonds (to push down long-term rates) and mortgage-backed securities (to support the housing market).

The contrast with 2020–2021 is striking: from February 2020 to December 2021, the monetary base rose ~85% but M1 jumped ~410% — implying banks reduced their reserve ratios (rr↓rr \downarrow, m↑m \uparrow), aggressively lending out their reserves.

Bank Failures in the Great Depression (1929–1933)

The 1930s Credit Crunch

Over 9,000 banks failed between 1929 and 1933, and the money supply fell 28% — despite the monetary base rising.

Variable Aug 1929 Mar 1933 % Change
MM 26.5 19.0 −28.3%
BB 7.1 8.4 +18.3%
mm 3.7 2.3 −37.8%
crcr 0.17 0.41 +141.2%
rrrr 0.14 0.21 +50.0%

What happened: Bank runs caused households to withdraw cash (cr↑cr \uparrow). Surviving banks, terrified of further runs, hoarded reserves instead of lending (rr↑rr \uparrow). Both effects crushed the money multiplier mm, causing MM to plummet even as BB rose.

m=1+crcr+rr:1+0.170.17+0.14=3.77  (1929)→1+0.410.41+0.21=2.27  (1933)m = \frac{1 + cr}{cr + rr}: \quad \frac{1+0.17}{0.17+0.14} = 3.77 \;\text{(1929)} \quad \to \quad \frac{1+0.41}{0.41+0.21} = 2.27 \;\text{(1933)}
Policy Response: Deposit Insurance

The Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) was created in 1933 specifically to prevent bank runs. If depositors know the government guarantees their deposits, they have no reason to panic-withdraw — stabilising crcr and the money multiplier.


Summary

The monetary system works through two interlocking mechanisms: the central bank controlling base money (BB), and the banking system amplifying base money through lending (the multiplier mm).

Money's three functions — medium of exchange, store of value, unit of account — make it useful. The fractional-reserve system is what makes it powerful: a $1 deposit can cascade into $5 of money supply. But this same leverage makes banks fragile; capital requirements exist to ensure banks can absorb losses without failing.

The four monetary policy tools (open market operations, discount rate, reserve requirements, interest on reserves) all work through either BB or mm — but because households control crcr and banks control excess reserves, the Fed's influence over MM is real but imprecise.

Concept Formula Key Driver
Money supply M=C+DM = C + D Banking system
Multiplier m=1+crcr+rrm = \frac{1+cr}{cr+rr} crcr, rrrr
Full money supply M=m⋅BM = m \cdot B Fed + banks + households
Bank solvency buffer Capital = Assets − Liabilities Leverage ratio