The Open Economy Revisited: The Mundell-Fleming Model and the Exchange-Rate Regime
- #macro-economics-ii
- #mundell-fleming
- #open-economy
- #exchange-rate
- #IS-LM
- #fiscal-policy
- #monetary-policy
- #trade-policy
- #floating-exchange-rate
- #fixed-exchange-rate
- #net-exports
- #country-risk
- #aggregate-demand
The Open Economy Revisited: The Mundell-Fleming Model and the Exchange-Rate Regime
Part of: Macro-Economics II | Key concepts: Mundell-Fleming Model, IS* Curve, LM* Curve, Floating Exchange Rate, Fixed Exchange Rate, Net Exports, Country Risk Premium, Aggregate Demand Curve
What This Chapter Is About
Chapter 12 showed how the IS-LM model describes a closed economy in the short run. Chapter 13 opens the economy up. The central tool is the Mundell-Fleming model, which extends IS-LM to a small open economy with perfect capital mobility.
The key payoff is a striking set of policy results:
- Under floating exchange rates: fiscal policy is ineffective at changing output; monetary policy is effective.
- Under fixed exchange rates: the results are exactly reversed — fiscal policy works, monetary policy does not.
Understanding why this is true is the real goal of the chapter.
The Mundell-Fleming Framework
Core Assumptions
The Mundell-Fleming model rests on two essential assumptions:
- Small open economy with perfect capital mobility:
The country can borrow and lend freely on world financial markets. Because the country is small, its own borrowing/lending has negligible effect on the world interest rate . Therefore:
The domestic interest rate is pinned by the world interest rate — it is exogenous from the country's perspective.
- Short run — prices fixed:
Like the standard IS-LM model, Mundell-Fleming takes as given. This means the nominal and real exchange rates move together in the short run (since and are fixed).
Why matters so muchIn a closed IS-LM model, the interest rate adjusts to equilibrate the money market and the goods market simultaneously. In the Mundell-Fleming model, is fixed at by international capital flows — so the money market must be cleared by alone. This single change reshapes all policy analysis.
The IS* and LM* Curves
The IS* Curve — Goods Market Equilibrium
The goods market equilibrium equation adds net exports to the standard IS identity:
Where:
- = the nominal exchange rate (units of foreign currency per unit of domestic currency; e.g. €/$). A higher means the domestic currency is stronger.
- is decreasing in — why?
- A stronger domestic currency (↑) makes domestic goods more expensive abroad → exports fall
- Foreign goods become cheaper at home → imports rise
- Both effects reduce
Since is exogenous, the IS* curve maps equilibrium combinations of :
IS* Slope — IntuitionHigher → ↓NX → ↓Y. So the IS* curve slopes downward in space (exchange rate on vertical axis, output on horizontal axis).
IS Shifts:*
| Shock | Direction of IS* shift |
|---|---|
| ↑ (fiscal expansion) | Rightward (↑Y at any ) |
| ↓ (tax cut) | Rightward |
| ↑ (world rate rises) | Leftward (↓I → ↓Y at any ) |
| ↑NX at given (e.g. import tariff) | Rightward |
The LM* Curve — Money Market Equilibrium
With exogenous and , both fixed, the only variable that can equilibrate the money market is . There is exactly one value of that clears the money market — regardless of .
LM* is VerticalThe LM* curve is a vertical line in space. The level of is determined entirely by , , and . Exchange rate movements do not affect money demand (money demand reflects liquidity preferences, not preferences for domestic vs. foreign currency).
LM Shifts:*
| Shock | Direction of LM* shift |
|---|---|
| ↑ (monetary expansion) | Rightward (↑Y to absorb extra real balances) |
| ↓ | Leftward |
| ↑ (world rate rises) | Leftward (↓L → need ↓Y to restore equilibrium) |
Economic logic for an ↑ shift:
↑ → → capital outflow → depreciates → NX↑ → ↑ → ↑ → rises back to ✓
Equilibrium in the Mundell-Fleming Model
The equilibrium is the intersection of IS* and LM*:
Policy Analysis — Floating Exchange Rates
Under floating rates, adjusts freely. The central bank does not intervene in the foreign exchange market — is controlled independently.
Fiscal Policy (e.g. ↑) — Floating Rates
Effect on IS:* Rightward shift (higher → higher planned expenditure → IS* shifts right)
But: LM* is vertical. The rightward shift of IS* raises (currency appreciates) but leaves unchanged.
Step-by-step intuition:
- ↑ temporarily raises
- Higher → higher demand for money → upward pressure on domestic
- even briefly → foreign capital flows in (chasing higher return)
- Demand for domestic currency rises → appreciates
- Higher → ↓NX → ↓ — Y returns to its original level
Complete Crowding Out — Open Economy StyleIn a closed economy, fiscal expansion crowds out investment (via rising ), but still rises.
In a small open economy with floating rates, fiscal expansion crowds out net exports (via appreciating ), and returns to exactly where it started. The multiplier is zero!
Comparison table:
| Dimension | Closed Economy (IS-LM) | Small Open, Floating (-) |
|---|---|---|
| Effect of ↑ on | ↑ | No change (pinned at ) |
| Effect of ↑ on | ↓ (crowded out) | No change |
| Effect of ↑ on | Slight ↓ | ↓ (fully crowded out) |
| Effect of ↑ on | ↑ | No change |
Monetary Policy (↑) — Floating Rates
Effect on LM:* Rightward shift → higher , lower
Step-by-step intuition:
- ↑ → excess real balances → downward pressure on
- briefly → domestic investors send capital abroad (seeking higher return)
- Demand for foreign currency rises → domestic currency depreciates (↓)
- Lower → ↑NX → ↑ → ↑ → rises back to
The transmission mechanism in a small open economy is:
Compare to the closed economy:
"Beggar-Thy-Neighbour" PolicyMonetary expansion in a small open economy does not raise world aggregate demand — it merely diverts demand from foreign to domestic goods by lowering . Income gains at home come at the expense of output losses abroad.
Trade Policy (e.g. Import Tariff/Quota) — Floating Rates
Effect on IS:* Rightward shift (import restriction → ↑NX at any → IS* right)
Result: appreciates, unchanged, and NX ends up unchanged.
Why does NX not change?
There is only one that clears the money market. Since , , , and are all unchanged, the national income identity forces to remain unchanged. The appreciation exactly offsets the trade restriction.
Import Restrictions Don't Fix Trade DeficitsTrade restrictions under floating rates: raise , reduce both imports (directly) and exports (via appreciation), leaving and unchanged. You get less trade with the same balance — destroying gains from trade without helping employment overall.
Policy Analysis — Fixed Exchange Rates
Under fixed rates, the central bank commits to maintaining at a pre-announced level . To do this, it buys/sells domestic currency in the foreign exchange market — which means it loses independent control of .
How the CB Defends the Peg
- If tends to appreciate above : CB sells domestic currency → ↑
- If tends to depreciate below : CB buys domestic currency → ↓ The CB shifts LM* as needed to keep .
Fiscal Policy (↑) — Fixed Rates
Under floating rates, ↑ would cause to appreciate. Under fixed rates, the CB prevents this by selling domestic currency (↑), which shifts LM* rightward.
Fiscal policy is very effective under fixed rates — the CB's accommodation eliminates the crowding-out of NX that would otherwise occur.
Monetary Policy (↑) — Fixed Rates
Under floating rates, ↑ would cause to depreciate. Under fixed rates, the CB must prevent this by buying domestic currency (↓), reversing the original expansion.
Monetary policy is completely ineffective under fixed exchange rates. The attempt to expand the money supply is immediately undone by the exchange rate defence.
Trade Policy — Fixed Rates
Under floating rates, an import restriction would appreciate and leave unchanged. Under fixed rates, the appreciation is prevented — the CB sells domestic currency (↑, LM* shifts right), and rises, as does .
However, the gains are beggar-thy-neighbour — demand is shifted from foreign to domestic goods.
Summary Table: Policy Effects in the Mundell-Fleming Model
| Policy | Floating: | Floating: | Floating: | Fixed: | Fixed: | Fixed: |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fiscal expansion (↑) | 0 | ↑ | ↓ | ↑ | 0 | 0 |
| Monetary expansion (↑) | ↑ | ↓ | ↑ | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Import restriction | 0 | ↑ | 0 | ↑ | 0 | ↑ |
The Big TakeawayFloating rates: Monetary policy works; fiscal policy doesn't.
Fixed rates: Fiscal policy works; monetary policy doesn't.
The regime determines which policy lever you have.
Interest Rate Differentials and Country Risk
So far we assumed exactly. In reality, countries face different borrowing costs for two reasons:
1. Country Risk Premium ()
Country risk is the risk that a country's borrowers will default due to political or economic instability. Lenders demand a premium (theta):
where reflects the extra return required to compensate for default risk.
2. Expected Exchange Rate Changes
If investors expect a currency to depreciate, assets denominated in that currency become less attractive — so lenders demand higher to compensate.
Effect of an Increase in in the M-F Model
Substituting into the IS* and LM* equations:
- IS* shifts left: Higher → ↓ → ↓ at any
- LM* shifts right: Higher → ↓ (higher opportunity cost of holding money) → must rise to restore money market equilibrium
The fall in is intuitive: A higher risk premium makes the domestic currency less attractive to hold → capital outflows → depreciates.
The rise in is counterintuitive and may not occur in practice:
- The CB may try to prevent depreciation by ↓ (LM* shifts left → ↓)
- Higher import prices may push up , reducing real balances (↓ → LM* left)
- Consumers may increase liquidity demand in response to uncertainty (→ ↓)
Self-Fulfilling CrisesAn expected depreciation causes a higher risk premium which causes actual depreciation. This is a self-fulfilling prophecy — currency crises can be driven purely by expectations, not fundamentals.
Deriving the AD Curve for a Small Open Economy
Introducing Real Exchange Rate
When prices can change, we must use the real exchange rate :
The IS* and LM* equations become:
Why the AD Curve Slopes Downward (Open Economy Mechanism)
In the closed IS-LM model, a higher reduces real balances , raises , reduces , and lowers . In the open economy, the mechanism is similar but operates through :
The AD curve therefore still slopes downward in space — but the channel is through net exports rather than investment.
| Economy Type | Transmission of ↑ to ↓ |
|---|---|
| Closed (IS-LM) | ↓ → ↑ → ↓ → ↓ |
| Small open (M-F) | ↓ → LM* left → ↑ → ↓ → ↓ |
Short Run to Long Run
If (below full employment): downward pressure on prices → ↓ → ↑ → LM* right → ↓ → ↑NX → ↑ back to
If : upward pressure on prices → ↑ → reverse of above → ↓ back to
Large Open Economy
Most countries — including the U.S. — are neither fully closed nor truly small open. A large open economy sits between the two extremes.
Three-Equation System
Key difference from small-open: is endogenous (not pinned at ). The country is large enough to affect world financial markets.
The third equation equates net exports (demand for domestic currency) with capital outflows (supply of domestic currency):
- ↓ → ↑NX → more demand for domestic currency
- ↓ → ↑CF → more supply of domestic currency (capital flows out)
Substituting NX = CF(r) into the IS equation: — looks just like a closed-economy IS curve (both and fall with ).
Rule of Thumb for Large Open Economy
Large Economy HeuristicA large open economy behaves as an average of a closed economy and a small open economy:
- Interest rate: moves in the same direction as in a closed economy (fiscal expansion → ↑r)
- Exchange rate: moves in the same direction as in a small open economy (fiscal expansion → ↑e, appreciation)
- Output: between the closed-economy and small-open-economy outcomes
Summary
The Mundell-Fleming model is the IS-LM model adapted for a small open economy under the key assumption :
The IS curve* (downward sloping in - space) describes goods market equilibrium: .
The LM curve* (vertical in - space) describes money market equilibrium: . It is vertical because alone can equilibrate the money market.
Policy effectiveness depends on the exchange rate regime:
- Floating rates: Monetary policy works (↑ → ↓ → ↑NX → ↑). Fiscal policy fails (↑ → ↑ → ↓NX → no change in ).
- Fixed rates: Fiscal policy works (CB accommodates by ↑). Monetary policy fails (any ↑ must be immediately reversed to defend peg).
Interest rate differentials: Country risk premium raises , depreciates , and ambiguously affects .
AD curve: In an open economy, ↑ reduces , shifts LM* left, appreciates , reduces NX, and lowers — giving the standard downward-sloping AD curve through a different channel than the closed economy.
Related Notes
- Lec_07-Aggregate Demand I & the IS-LM Model — Foundation: the IS and LM curves in a closed economy
- Lec_08-Aggregate Demand II & Applying the IS-LM Model — Policy analysis with IS-LM (closed economy baseline)
- Lec_06-AS-AD Model & Economic Fluctuations — The AD-AS framework this feeds into
- Macro-Economics II — Subject hub