Week 9 · Alon Cohen

The Open Economy Revisited: The Mundell-Fleming Model and the Exchange-Rate Regime

The Open Economy Revisited: The Mundell-Fleming Model and the Exchange-Rate Regime

Part of: Macro-Economics II | Key concepts: Mundell-Fleming Model, IS* Curve, LM* Curve, Floating Exchange Rate, Fixed Exchange Rate, Net Exports, Country Risk Premium, Aggregate Demand Curve


What This Chapter Is About

Chapter 12 showed how the IS-LM model describes a closed economy in the short run. Chapter 13 opens the economy up. The central tool is the Mundell-Fleming model, which extends IS-LM to a small open economy with perfect capital mobility.

The key payoff is a striking set of policy results:

  • Under floating exchange rates: fiscal policy is ineffective at changing output; monetary policy is effective.
  • Under fixed exchange rates: the results are exactly reversed — fiscal policy works, monetary policy does not.

Understanding why this is true is the real goal of the chapter.


The Mundell-Fleming Framework

Core Assumptions

The Mundell-Fleming model rests on two essential assumptions:

  1. Small open economy with perfect capital mobility:
    The country can borrow and lend freely on world financial markets. Because the country is small, its own borrowing/lending has negligible effect on the world interest rate r∗r^*. Therefore:
r=r∗\boxed{r = r^*}

The domestic interest rate is pinned by the world interest rate — it is exogenous from the country's perspective.

  1. Short run — prices fixed:
    Like the standard IS-LM model, Mundell-Fleming takes Pˉ\bar{P} as given. This means the nominal and real exchange rates move together in the short run (since ε=eP/P∗\varepsilon = eP/P^* and P,P∗P,P^* are fixed).
Why r=r∗r = r^* matters so much

In a closed IS-LM model, the interest rate adjusts to equilibrate the money market and the goods market simultaneously. In the Mundell-Fleming model, rr is fixed at r∗r^* by international capital flows — so the money market must be cleared by YY alone. This single change reshapes all policy analysis.


The IS* and LM* Curves

The IS* Curve — Goods Market Equilibrium

The goods market equilibrium equation adds net exports NX(e)NX(e) to the standard IS identity:

Y=C(Y−T)+I(r∗)+G+NX(e)\boxed{Y = C(Y-T) + I(r^*) + G + NX(e)}

Where:

  • ee = the nominal exchange rate (units of foreign currency per unit of domestic currency; e.g. €/$). A higher ee means the domestic currency is stronger.
  • NX(e)NX(e) is decreasing in ee — why?
    • A stronger domestic currency (↑ee) makes domestic goods more expensive abroad → exports fall
    • Foreign goods become cheaper at home → imports rise
    • Both effects reduce NXNX

Since r∗r^* is exogenous, the IS* curve maps equilibrium combinations of (e,Y)(e, Y):

IS* Slope — Intuition

Higher ee → ↓NX → ↓Y. So the IS* curve slopes downward in (e,Y)(e, Y) space (exchange rate on vertical axis, output on horizontal axis).

IS Shifts:*

Shock Direction of IS* shift
↑GG (fiscal expansion) Rightward (↑Y at any ee)
↓TT (tax cut) Rightward
↑r∗r^* (world rate rises) Leftward (↓I → ↓Y at any ee)
↑NX at given ee (e.g. import tariff) Rightward

The LM* Curve — Money Market Equilibrium

MP=L(r∗,Y)\boxed{\frac{M}{P} = L(r^*, Y)}

With r∗r^* exogenous and MM, PP both fixed, the only variable that can equilibrate the money market is YY. There is exactly one value of YY that clears the money market — regardless of ee.

LM* is Vertical

The LM* curve is a vertical line in (e,Y)(e, Y) space. The level of YY is determined entirely by MM, PP, and r∗r^*. Exchange rate movements do not affect money demand (money demand reflects liquidity preferences, not preferences for domestic vs. foreign currency).

LM Shifts:*

Shock Direction of LM* shift
↑MM (monetary expansion) Rightward (↑Y to absorb extra real balances)
↓MM Leftward
↑r∗r^* (world rate rises) Leftward (↓L → need ↓Y to restore equilibrium)

Economic logic for an ↑MM shift:
MM↑ → r<r∗r < r^* → capital outflow → ee depreciates → NX↑ → YY↑ → LL↑ → rr rises back to r∗r^* ✓

Equilibrium in the Mundell-Fleming Model

The equilibrium (e∗,Y∗)(e^*, Y^*) is the intersection of IS* and LM*:

Y∗ determined by LM* (vertical),e∗ determined by IS*Y^* \text{ determined by LM* (vertical)}, \quad e^* \text{ determined by IS*}

Policy Analysis — Floating Exchange Rates

Under floating rates, ee adjusts freely. The central bank does not intervene in the foreign exchange market — MM is controlled independently.

Fiscal Policy (e.g. ↑GG) — Floating Rates

Effect on IS:* Rightward shift (higher GG → higher planned expenditure → IS* shifts right)

But: LM* is vertical. The rightward shift of IS* raises ee (currency appreciates) but leaves YY unchanged.

ΔG>0⇒Δe>0,ΔY=0\boxed{\Delta G > 0 \Rightarrow \Delta e > 0, \quad \Delta Y = 0}

Step-by-step intuition:

  1. ↑GG temporarily raises YY
  2. Higher YY → higher demand for money LL → upward pressure on domestic rr
  3. r>r∗r > r^* even briefly → foreign capital flows in (chasing higher return)
  4. Demand for domestic currency rises → ee appreciates
  5. Higher ee → ↓NX → ↓YY — Y returns to its original level
Complete Crowding Out — Open Economy Style

In a closed economy, fiscal expansion crowds out investment (via rising rr), but YY still rises.
In a small open economy with floating rates, fiscal expansion crowds out net exports (via appreciating ee), and YY returns to exactly where it started. The multiplier is zero!

Comparison table:

Dimension Closed Economy (IS-LM) Small Open, Floating (MM-FF)
Effect of ↑GG on rr ↑ No change (pinned at r∗r^*)
Effect of ↑GG on II ↓ (crowded out) No change
Effect of ↑GG on NXNX Slight ↓ ↓ (fully crowded out)
Effect of ↑GG on YY ↑ No change

Monetary Policy (↑MM) — Floating Rates

Effect on LM:* Rightward shift → higher YY, lower ee

ΔM>0⇒Δe<0 (depreciation),ΔY>0\boxed{\Delta M > 0 \Rightarrow \Delta e < 0 \text{ (depreciation)}, \quad \Delta Y > 0}

Step-by-step intuition:

  1. ↑MM → excess real balances → downward pressure on rr
  2. r<r∗r < r^* briefly → domestic investors send capital abroad (seeking higher return)
  3. Demand for foreign currency rises → domestic currency depreciates (↓ee)
  4. Lower ee → ↑NX → ↑YY → ↑LL → rr rises back to r∗r^*

The transmission mechanism in a small open economy is:

M↑→e↓→NX↑→Y↑M \uparrow \rightarrow e \downarrow \rightarrow NX \uparrow \rightarrow Y \uparrow

Compare to the closed economy: M↑→r↓→I↑→Y↑M \uparrow \rightarrow r \downarrow \rightarrow I \uparrow \rightarrow Y \uparrow

"Beggar-Thy-Neighbour" Policy

Monetary expansion in a small open economy does not raise world aggregate demand — it merely diverts demand from foreign to domestic goods by lowering ee. Income gains at home come at the expense of output losses abroad.

Trade Policy (e.g. Import Tariff/Quota) — Floating Rates

Effect on IS:* Rightward shift (import restriction → ↑NX at any ee → IS* right)

Result: ee appreciates, YY unchanged, and NX ends up unchanged.

Import restriction⇒Δe>0,ΔY=0,ΔNX=0\boxed{\text{Import restriction} \Rightarrow \Delta e > 0, \quad \Delta Y = 0, \quad \Delta NX = 0}

Why does NX not change?
There is only one YY that clears the money market. Since YY, CC, II, and GG are all unchanged, the national income identity NX=Y−(C+I+G)NX = Y - (C + I + G) forces NXNX to remain unchanged. The appreciation exactly offsets the trade restriction.

Import Restrictions Don't Fix Trade Deficits

Trade restrictions under floating rates: raise ee, reduce both imports (directly) and exports (via appreciation), leaving NXNX and YY unchanged. You get less trade with the same balance — destroying gains from trade without helping employment overall.


Policy Analysis — Fixed Exchange Rates

Under fixed rates, the central bank commits to maintaining ee at a pre-announced level eˉ\bar{e}. To do this, it buys/sells domestic currency in the foreign exchange market — which means it loses independent control of MM.

How the CB Defends the Peg
  • If ee tends to appreciate above eˉ\bar{e}: CB sells domestic currency → MM↑
  • If ee tends to depreciate below eˉ\bar{e}: CB buys domestic currency → MM↓ The CB shifts LM* as needed to keep e=eˉe = \bar{e}.

Fiscal Policy (↑GG) — Fixed Rates

Under floating rates, ↑GG would cause ee to appreciate. Under fixed rates, the CB prevents this by selling domestic currency (↑MM), which shifts LM* rightward.

ΔG>0⇒Δe=0,ΔY>0\boxed{\Delta G > 0 \Rightarrow \Delta e = 0, \quad \Delta Y > 0}

Fiscal policy is very effective under fixed rates — the CB's accommodation eliminates the crowding-out of NX that would otherwise occur.

Monetary Policy (↑MM) — Fixed Rates

Under floating rates, ↑MM would cause ee to depreciate. Under fixed rates, the CB must prevent this by buying domestic currency (↓MM), reversing the original expansion.

ΔM>0⇒CB must reverse⇒Δe=0,ΔY=0\boxed{\Delta M > 0 \Rightarrow \text{CB must reverse} \Rightarrow \Delta e = 0, \quad \Delta Y = 0}

Monetary policy is completely ineffective under fixed exchange rates. The attempt to expand the money supply is immediately undone by the exchange rate defence.

Trade Policy — Fixed Rates

Under floating rates, an import restriction would appreciate ee and leave NXNX unchanged. Under fixed rates, the appreciation is prevented — the CB sells domestic currency (↑MM, LM* shifts right), and YY rises, as does NXNX.

Import restriction⇒Δe=0,ΔY>0,ΔNX>0\boxed{\text{Import restriction} \Rightarrow \Delta e = 0, \quad \Delta Y > 0, \quad \Delta NX > 0}

However, the gains are beggar-thy-neighbour — demand is shifted from foreign to domestic goods.


Summary Table: Policy Effects in the Mundell-Fleming Model

Policy Floating: ΔY\Delta Y Floating: Δe\Delta e Floating: ΔNX\Delta NX Fixed: ΔY\Delta Y Fixed: Δe\Delta e Fixed: ΔNX\Delta NX
Fiscal expansion (↑GG) 0 ↑ ↓ ↑ 0 0
Monetary expansion (↑MM) ↑ ↓ ↑ 0 0 0
Import restriction 0 ↑ 0 ↑ 0 ↑
The Big Takeaway

Floating rates: Monetary policy works; fiscal policy doesn't.
Fixed rates: Fiscal policy works; monetary policy doesn't.
The regime determines which policy lever you have.


Interest Rate Differentials and Country Risk

So far we assumed r=r∗r = r^* exactly. In reality, countries face different borrowing costs for two reasons:

1. Country Risk Premium (θ\theta)

Country risk is the risk that a country's borrowers will default due to political or economic instability. Lenders demand a premium θ\theta (theta):

r=r∗+θ\boxed{r = r^* + \theta}

where θ≥0\theta \geq 0 reflects the extra return required to compensate for default risk.

2. Expected Exchange Rate Changes

If investors expect a currency to depreciate, assets denominated in that currency become less attractive — so lenders demand higher rr to compensate.

Effect of an Increase in θ\theta in the M-F Model

Substituting r=r∗+θr = r^* + \theta into the IS* and LM* equations:

  • IS* shifts left: Higher rr → ↓II → ↓YY at any ee
  • LM* shifts right: Higher rr → ↓LL (higher opportunity cost of holding money) → YY must rise to restore money market equilibrium
Δθ>0⇒Δe<0 (depreciation),ΔY>0 (theory)\boxed{\Delta \theta > 0 \Rightarrow \Delta e < 0 \text{ (depreciation)}, \quad \Delta Y > 0 \text{ (theory)}}

The fall in ee is intuitive: A higher risk premium makes the domestic currency less attractive to hold → capital outflows → ee depreciates.

The rise in YY is counterintuitive and may not occur in practice:

  • The CB may try to prevent depreciation by ↓MM (LM* shifts left → ↓YY)
  • Higher import prices may push up PP, reducing real balances (↓M/PM/P → LM* left)
  • Consumers may increase liquidity demand LL in response to uncertainty (→ ↓YY)
Self-Fulfilling Crises

An expected depreciation causes a higher risk premium θ\theta which causes actual depreciation. This is a self-fulfilling prophecy — currency crises can be driven purely by expectations, not fundamentals.


Deriving the AD Curve for a Small Open Economy

Introducing Real Exchange Rate

When prices can change, we must use the real exchange rate ε\varepsilon:

ε=e⋅PP∗\varepsilon = \frac{e \cdot P}{P^*}

The IS* and LM* equations become:

IS*: Y=C(Y−T)+I(r∗)+G+NX(ε)\text{IS*: } Y = C(Y-T) + I(r^*) + G + NX(\varepsilon)
LM*: MP=L(r∗,Y)\text{LM*: } \frac{M}{P} = L(r^*, Y)

Why the AD Curve Slopes Downward (Open Economy Mechanism)

In the closed IS-LM model, a higher PP reduces real balances (M/P)(M/P), raises rr, reduces II, and lowers YY. In the open economy, the mechanism is similar but operates through ε\varepsilon:

P↑→MP↓→LM* shifts left→ε↑→NX↓→Y↓P \uparrow \rightarrow \frac{M}{P} \downarrow \rightarrow \text{LM* shifts left} \rightarrow \varepsilon \uparrow \rightarrow NX \downarrow \rightarrow Y \downarrow

The AD curve therefore still slopes downward in (P,Y)(P, Y) space — but the channel is through net exports rather than investment.

Economy Type Transmission of ↑PP to ↓YY
Closed (IS-LM) ↓(M/P)(M/P) → ↑rr → ↓II → ↓YY
Small open (M-F) ↓(M/P)(M/P) → LM* left → ↑ε\varepsilon → ↓NXNX → ↓YY

Short Run to Long Run

If Y<YˉY < \bar{Y} (below full employment): downward pressure on prices → PP↓ → ↑(M/P)(M/P) → LM* right → ↓ε\varepsilon → ↑NX → YY↑ back to Yˉ\bar{Y}

If Y>YˉY > \bar{Y}: upward pressure on prices → PP↑ → reverse of above → YY↓ back to Yˉ\bar{Y}


Large Open Economy

Most countries — including the U.S. — are neither fully closed nor truly small open. A large open economy sits between the two extremes.

Three-Equation System

MP=L(r,Y)(LM — same as closed)\frac{M}{P} = L(r, Y) \quad \text{(LM — same as closed)}
Y=C(Y−T)+I(r)+G+NX(e)(IS — same as MF)Y = C(Y-T) + I(r) + G + NX(e) \quad \text{(IS — same as MF)}
NX(e)=CF(r)(Balance of payments)NX(e) = CF(r) \quad \text{(Balance of payments)}

Key difference from small-open: rr is endogenous (not pinned at r∗r^*). The country is large enough to affect world financial markets.

The third equation equates net exports (demand for domestic currency) with capital outflows CF(r)CF(r) (supply of domestic currency):

  • ↓ee → ↑NX → more demand for domestic currency
  • ↓rr → ↑CF → more supply of domestic currency (capital flows out)

Substituting NX = CF(r) into the IS equation: Y=C(Y−T)+I(r)+G+CF(r)Y = C(Y-T) + I(r) + G + CF(r) — looks just like a closed-economy IS curve (both II and CFCF fall with rr).

Rule of Thumb for Large Open Economy

Large Economy Heuristic

A large open economy behaves as an average of a closed economy and a small open economy:

  • Interest rate: moves in the same direction as in a closed economy (fiscal expansion → ↑r)
  • Exchange rate: moves in the same direction as in a small open economy (fiscal expansion → ↑e, appreciation)
  • Output: between the closed-economy and small-open-economy outcomes

Summary

The Mundell-Fleming model is the IS-LM model adapted for a small open economy under the key assumption r=r∗r = r^*:

The IS curve* (downward sloping in ee-YY space) describes goods market equilibrium: Y=C(Y−T)+I(r∗)+G+NX(e)Y = C(Y-T) + I(r^*) + G + NX(e).

The LM curve* (vertical in ee-YY space) describes money market equilibrium: M/P=L(r∗,Y)M/P = L(r^*, Y). It is vertical because YY alone can equilibrate the money market.

Policy effectiveness depends on the exchange rate regime:

  • Floating rates: Monetary policy works (↑MM → ↓ee → ↑NX → ↑YY). Fiscal policy fails (↑GG → ↑ee → ↓NX → no change in YY).
  • Fixed rates: Fiscal policy works (CB accommodates by ↑MM). Monetary policy fails (any ↑MM must be immediately reversed to defend peg).

Interest rate differentials: Country risk premium θ\theta raises r=r∗+θr = r^* + \theta, depreciates ee, and ambiguously affects YY.

AD curve: In an open economy, ↑PP reduces (M/P)(M/P), shifts LM* left, appreciates ε\varepsilon, reduces NX, and lowers YY — giving the standard downward-sloping AD curve through a different channel than the closed economy.