Week 7 · Alon Cohen

Aggregate Demand I: Building the IS-LM Model

Aggregate Demand I: Building the IS-LM Model

Part of: Macro-Economics II | Key concepts: IS Curve, LM Curve, Keynesian Cross, Liquidity Preference, Fiscal Multiplier, Money Demand, Short-Run Equilibrium, Aggregate Demand


What This Chapter Is About

Chapter 10 introduced the AS-AD framework and the concept of price stickiness in the short run. Chapter 11 builds the demand side in detail — specifically the IS-LM model, which is the backbone of modern short-run macroeconomics.

The IS-LM model simultaneously determines the interest rate (rr) and output (YY) by requiring equilibrium in two markets at once:

  • The goods market — planned expenditure equals actual output (captured by the IS curve)
  • The money market — supply of real money balances equals demand (captured by the LM curve)

The IS-LM model is the analytical engine behind the aggregate demand curve studied in chapters 11–14. Think of it as "opening up the black box" of the AD curve to show why aggregate demand slopes downward and how policy shifts it.

Where We Are in the Course
Chapter Focus
3–5 Long-run real and nominal sides (classical model)
8–9 Very long-run: growth theory
10 Short-run intro: AS-AD, price stickiness
11 Building IS-LM (demand side)
12–14 Using IS-LM: policy analysis, open economy

Key assumption throughout this chapter: Prices PP are fixed in the short run. This means we do not yet worry about the supply side — all action is on the demand side. The equilibrium YY is demand-determined.


Part 1: The Keynesian Cross

The Core Idea

The Keynesian cross is the simplest model of output determination in a closed economy. It says: output is determined by planned expenditure — in equilibrium, what firms produce equals what people plan to spend.

Notation:

  • CC = household consumption
  • II = planned (business) investment
  • GG = government purchases
  • TT = taxes
  • PE=C+I+GPE = C + I + G = planned expenditure
  • YY = real GDP = actual expenditure

Equilibrium condition:

Y=PE=C(Y−T)+I+G\boxed{Y = PE = C(Y-T) + I + G}

The consumption function C(Y−T)C(Y-T) captures that consumption rises with disposable income (Y−T)(Y - T). The MPC (marginal propensity to consume) is the slope: 0<MPC<10 < MPC < 1.

Why the Model Works: Inventory Adjustment

If prices are fixed (and the interest rate is temporarily assumed fixed too), how does the economy reach equilibrium? Through unplanned inventory changes:

Adjustment Mechanism
  • If PE>YPE > Y: spending exceeds output → inventories fall below planned levels → firms increase production
  • If PE<YPE < Y: output exceeds spending → inventories pile up above planned levels → firms cut production
  • Equilibrium: PE=YPE = Y → no unplanned inventory change

This is why the 45° line matters: it shows all points where actual output = planned expenditure. The economy always gravitates toward the intersection of the PE line and the 45° line.

The Fiscal Multiplier: Government Purchases

When GG rises by ΔG\Delta G, what happens to equilibrium output?

Derivation:

Starting from Y=C(Y−T)+I+GY = C(Y-T) + I + G, take changes:

ΔY=MPC⋅ΔY⏟ΔC+ΔG\Delta Y = \underbrace{MPC \cdot \Delta Y}_{\Delta C} + \Delta G
ΔY−MPC⋅ΔY=ΔG\Delta Y - MPC \cdot \Delta Y = \Delta G
ΔY(1−MPC)=ΔG\Delta Y(1 - MPC) = \Delta G
ΔYΔG=11−MPC\boxed{\frac{\Delta Y}{\Delta G} = \frac{1}{1 - MPC}}
Why Is the Multiplier > 1?

The initial ΔG\Delta G raises income by ΔG\Delta G. This extra income causes households to spend MPC⋅ΔGMPC \cdot \Delta G more. That extra spending creates more income, which creates more spending… The total effect is the sum of a geometric series: ΔY=ΔG⋅(1+MPC+MPC2+…)=ΔG1−MPC\Delta Y = \Delta G \cdot (1 + MPC + MPC^2 + \ldots) = \frac{\Delta G}{1 - MPC} If MPC=0.8MPC = 0.8, the multiplier is 11−0.8=5\frac{1}{1-0.8} = 5. A €1 rise in GG raises output by €5!

The Tax Multiplier

An increase in taxes ΔT\Delta T reduces disposable income, which reduces consumption, which reduces PEPE and hence YY.

Derivation:

ΔY=MPC⋅Δ(Y−T)=MPC(ΔY−ΔT)\Delta Y = MPC \cdot \Delta(Y - T) = MPC(\Delta Y - \Delta T)
ΔY(1−MPC)=−MPC⋅ΔT\Delta Y(1 - MPC) = -MPC \cdot \Delta T
ΔYΔT=−MPC1−MPC\boxed{\frac{\Delta Y}{\Delta T} = \frac{-MPC}{1 - MPC}}
Comparing the Two Multipliers
Policy change Multiplier (MPC = 0.8) Direction
↑ Government purchases ΔG\Delta G +5+5 Output rises
↑ Taxes ΔT\Delta T −4-4 Output falls

The tax multiplier is smaller in absolute value than the spending multiplier. Why? When government spends €1 more, all €1 enters the expenditure stream immediately. When taxes fall by €1, households save (1−MPC)(1-MPC) of the tax cut, so only MPCMPC of €1 enters the expenditure stream. Saving "leaks" out of the multiplier process.

Common Mistake: Balanced Budget Multiplier

If ΔG=ΔT\Delta G = \Delta T (a balanced budget expansion), the net effect is NOT zero. The spending multiplier dominates, and output rises by exactly ΔG\Delta G. This is the balanced budget multiplier = 1 result.


Part 2: The IS Curve

From Keynesian Cross to the IS Curve

The Keynesian cross assumed a fixed interest rate — investment was exogenous. Now we relax this. Planned investment depends negatively on the real interest rate rr: when borrowing is expensive, firms invest less.

I=I(r),dIdr<0I = I(r), \quad \frac{dI}{dr} < 0

The IS curve shows all (r,Y)(r, Y) combinations where the goods market is in equilibrium:

Y=C(Y−T)+I(r)+G\boxed{Y = C(Y-T) + I(r) + G}

Derivation of IS curve shape:

When rr falls → I(r)I(r) rises → PEPE shifts up → Keynesian cross gives higher YY
When rr rises → I(r)I(r) falls → PEPE shifts down → lower YY

Therefore the IS curve is downward sloping in (r,Y)(r, Y) space — lower interest rates are associated with higher output.

Intuition for the IS Curve Slope

A lower interest rate makes investment cheaper. Firms borrow and invest more, which raises planned expenditure. Since PE=YPE = Y in equilibrium, output must rise to match the new higher spending. So: r↓⇒I↑⇒PE↑⇒Y↑r \downarrow \Rightarrow I \uparrow \Rightarrow PE \uparrow \Rightarrow Y \uparrow. Negative slope.

Fiscal Policy and IS Curve Shifts

For any given interest rate rr:

  • Expansionary fiscal policy (↑G\uparrow G or ↓T\downarrow T): raises PEPE → raises equilibrium YY → IS shifts right
  • Contractionary fiscal policy (↓G\downarrow G or ↑T\uparrow T): reduces PEPE → IS shifts left

The horizontal shift of the IS curve from a change in GG equals the Keynesian cross multiplier times ΔG\Delta G:

ΔY∣r fixed=11−MPC⋅ΔG\Delta Y\Big|_{r \text{ fixed}} = \frac{1}{1-MPC} \cdot \Delta G
IS Curve: Summary Table
Factor Effect on IS curve
↑ G or ↓ T (expansionary fiscal) Shifts right
↓ G or ↑ T (contractionary fiscal) Shifts left
↓ r (along the IS curve) Movement down/right along curve
↑ Investment optimism (↑I\uparrow I autonomous) Shifts right

Part 3: Theory of Liquidity Preference

Keynes's Theory of Money Market Equilibrium

The theory of liquidity preference (Keynes) explains the interest rate as being determined by money supply and money demand. This gives us the LM curve.

Key variable: Real money balances =M/P= M/P

  • MM = nominal money supply (controlled by the central bank)
  • PP = price level (fixed in the short run)

Since PP is fixed, controlling MM is equivalent to controlling M/PM/P.

Money Supply

The central bank fixes the supply of real money balances:

(MP)s=MP‾\left(\frac{M}{P}\right)^s = \overline{\frac{M}{P}}

This is a vertical line in (M/P,r)(M/P, r) space — the supply doesn't depend on the interest rate.

How the CB controls MM:

  • Open market operations: buying bonds from the public → injects money; selling bonds → withdraws money
  • Banking regulation: affecting reserve requirements changes banks' willingness to create deposits (loans create deposits)

Money Demand

People hold money for transactions and liquidity. But holding money has an opportunity cost — the interest foregone by not holding bonds. Therefore money demand depends negatively on rr:

(MP)d=L(r,Y)\left(\frac{M}{P}\right)^d = L(r, Y)

where ∂L∂r<0\frac{\partial L}{\partial r} < 0 and ∂L∂Y>0\frac{\partial L}{\partial Y} > 0.

Why Does Money Demand Fall When rr Rises?

The nominal interest rate is the cost of holding money rather than bonds. When rr is high, the temptation to hold bonds (interest-bearing) rather than cash (non-interest-bearing) is strong. People economize on cash balances. Hence money demand is decreasing in rr.

Equilibrium in the money market:

MP=L(r)\frac{M}{P} = L(r)

The interest rate adjusts to clear the money market. If there's excess demand for money (people want more cash), they sell bonds → bond prices fall → interest rate rises until equilibrium is restored.

Monetary Policy and the Interest Rate

  • Expansionary monetary policy (M↑M \uparrow): shifts money supply right → at the old rr, supply exceeds demand → people buy bonds → bond prices rise → rr falls
  • Contractionary monetary policy (M↓M \downarrow): supply shifts left → people sell bonds → rr rises
Short-Run vs Long-Run: The Fisher Effect Paradox

In the long run (Chapter 5), higher MM leads to inflation and, via the Fisher effect, higher nominal interest rates. But here in the short run, higher MM lowers rr. Is this a contradiction?

No! The economy behaves differently across time horizons:

  • Short run: PP is sticky. M↑⇒M/P↑⇒r↓M \uparrow \Rightarrow M/P \uparrow \Rightarrow r \downarrow (real effect)
  • Long run: the lower rr boosts output and demand → prices rise proportionally to MM → M/PM/P returns to original level → money neutrality restored → Fisher effect drives rr back up

Case Study: Volcker Disinflation (1979–80)

Paul Volcker (Fed Chair) dramatically tightened monetary policy in late 1979 to crush 10%+ inflation.

Prediction Actual Outcome
Short run (Keynesian liquidity preference) M↓⇒r↑M \downarrow \Rightarrow r \uparrow Aug 1979: i=10.4%i = 10.4\% → Apr 1980: i=15.8%i = 15.8\% ✓
Long run (Classical Fisher effect) π↓⇒i↓\pi \downarrow \Rightarrow i \downarrow Jan 1983: π=3.7%\pi = 3.7\%, i=8.2%i = 8.2\% ✓

Both models are correct — they just apply to different time horizons. The key is whether prices are sticky (SR) or flexible (LR).


Part 4: The LM Curve

Incorporating Income into Money Demand

So far we assumed money demand depends only on rr. But higher income YY means more transactions → more need for cash → higher money demand:

(MP)d=L(r,Y),∂L∂Y>0\left(\frac{M}{P}\right)^d = L(r, Y), \quad \frac{\partial L}{\partial Y} > 0

The LM curve shows all (r,Y)(r, Y) combinations where the money market is in equilibrium:

MP=L(r,Y)\boxed{\frac{M}{P} = L(r, Y)}

Why the LM Curve is Upward Sloping

When YY rises → transactions demand for money rises → at the old rr, there is excess demand for money → people sell bonds → bond prices fall → rr rises

Therefore higher YY is associated with higher rr in money market equilibrium → the LM curve is upward sloping in (r,Y)(r, Y) space.

Intuition for LM Curve Slope

Think of a fixed money supply being "stretched" across more economic activity. More income means more transactions — people need more cash. Since supply is fixed, competition for liquidity bids up the price of money — the interest rate. So Y↑⇒Ld↑⇒r↑Y \uparrow \Rightarrow L^d \uparrow \Rightarrow r \uparrow to restore equilibrium.

Monetary Policy and LM Curve Shifts

For any given income level YY:

  • Expansionary monetary policy (M↑M \uparrow, or equivalently M/P↑M/P \uparrow): money supply shifts right → at old rr, supply exceeds demand → rr falls → LM shifts right/downward (lower rr for same YY)
  • Contractionary monetary policy (M↓M \downarrow): LM shifts left/upward (higher rr for same YY)
LM Curve: Summary Table
Factor Effect on LM curve
↑ M (expansionary monetary policy) Shifts right/down
↓ M (contractionary monetary policy) Shifts left/up
↑ Y (along the LM curve) Movement up/right along curve
↑ Money demand (e.g. more cash use) Shifts left/up
Credit Card Fraud and the LM Curve

If fraud causes consumers to use cash more, money demand L(r,Y)L(r, Y) rises at every (r,Y)(r, Y). This is an increase in money demand → equivalent to a leftward shift of money supply → LM shifts up/left → at any income level, the interest rate needed to equilibrate the money market is now higher.


Part 5: IS-LM Equilibrium

Simultaneous Goods and Money Market Equilibrium

The short-run equilibrium of the economy is the unique (Y∗,r∗)(Y^*, r^*) that satisfies both equilibrium conditions simultaneously:

IS: Y=C(Y−T)+I(r)+G\text{IS: } Y = C(Y-T) + I(r) + G
LM: MP=L(r,Y)\text{LM: } \frac{M}{P} = L(r, Y)

Graphically, this is the intersection of the IS and LM curves.

(Y∗,r∗)=IS∩LM\boxed{(Y^*, r^*) = \text{IS} \cap \text{LM}}
What Each Curve Pins Down
  • The IS curve: for any rr, what level of YY clears the goods market?
  • The LM curve: for any YY, what level of rr clears the money market?
  • Together: a unique (Y∗,r∗)(Y^*, r^*) that clears both simultaneously

The Big Picture: Where IS-LM Fits

The IS-LM model is the engine that generates the aggregate demand (AD) curve. When the price level PP changes, the real money supply M/PM/P changes, the LM curve shifts, and a new IS-LM equilibrium gives a new YY. Tracing out how YY changes as PP changes gives the AD curve.

Keynesian Cross → IS curve
                              ↘
                               IS-LM model → AD curve → AD-AS model → Explains fluctuations
                              ↗
Liquidity Preference → LM curve

We are currently at the IS-LM stage. Chapters 12–14 use IS-LM to analyse policy in a closed and open economy before deriving the full AD-AS framework.


Summary Table: IS vs LM

Feature IS Curve LM Curve
Market Goods market Money market
Equilibrium condition Y=C(Y−T)+I(r)+GY = C(Y-T) + I(r) + G M/P=L(r,Y)M/P = L(r, Y)
Slope in (r,Y)(r, Y) space Downward sloping Upward sloping
Key relationship r↓⇒I↑⇒Y↑r \downarrow \Rightarrow I \uparrow \Rightarrow Y \uparrow Y↑⇒Ld↑⇒r↑Y \uparrow \Rightarrow L^d \uparrow \Rightarrow r \uparrow
Shifts right when ↑G\uparrow G, ↓T\downarrow T, ↑I\uparrow I autonomous ↑M\uparrow M (exp. monetary policy)
Shifts left when ↓G\downarrow G, ↑T\uparrow T ↓M\downarrow M (cont. monetary policy)
Policy tool Fiscal policy Monetary policy

Summary

  1. Keynesian cross: the simplest model of income determination. Output adjusts to equate planned expenditure (PEPE) with actual output (YY). Fiscal policy has multiplier effects: ΔY/ΔG=1/(1−MPC)\Delta Y / \Delta G = 1/(1-MPC); tax multiplier is −MPC/(1−MPC)-MPC/(1-MPC) (smaller in absolute value because of saving leakage).

  2. IS curve: derived from the Keynesian cross by allowing investment to depend on the interest rate. Shows all (r,Y)(r, Y) pairs consistent with goods market equilibrium. Downward sloping — lower rr → more investment → higher YY. Expansionary fiscal policy shifts IS right; contractionary shifts it left.

  3. Theory of liquidity preference: interest rate is determined by money supply and money demand. Money demand L(r)L(r) falls with rr (opportunity cost). Money supply is fixed by the CB. Expansionary monetary policy lowers rr in the short run (LM/Keynesian); raises rr in the long run (Fisher/Classical).

  4. LM curve: derived from liquidity preference by allowing money demand to depend on income. Shows all (r,Y)(r, Y) pairs consistent with money market equilibrium. Upward sloping — higher YY → more money demand → higher rr to restore equilibrium. Expansionary monetary policy shifts LM right/down.

  5. IS-LM equilibrium: the intersection of IS and LM simultaneously clears both the goods market and the money market, pinning down both output Y∗Y^* and the interest rate r∗r^*. This intersection is the foundation of the aggregate demand curve.