Week 3 · Alon Cohen

Classical Theory & National Income

Classical Theory & National Income

Part of: Macro-Economics II | Key concepts: Production Function, Loanable Funds Market, Cobb-Douglas, National Saving, Classical Dichotomy, Marginal Product


Course Overview

Lecturer: Alon Cohen — alonc17@gmail.com
TA: Yosi Ganel — gyosi@runi.ac.il

Assessment Weight
Final exam (25 MCQ) 70%
8 home quizzes (best 6 × 5%) 30%
Minimum final exam score to pass 55
Where Chapter 3 fits

This chapter reviews the Classical (long-run) model of the macroeconomy — the benchmark everything else is measured against. It tells us how output, income, saving, and investment are determined when prices are flexible and factors are fully employed.


The Three Dichotomies of Macro

Before diving into the model, it helps to understand the three axes along which macroeconomists organise their thinking:

1. Open vs. Closed Economy

Feature Closed Economy Open Economy
Trade in goods ❌ ✅
Capital mobility ❌ ✅
Currency exchange ❌ ✅

Chapter 3 focuses on the closed economy — a useful simplification that captures the core logic before adding international complications.

2. Real vs. Nominal

Side Variables Units
Real GDP, investment, unemployment, real interest rate Physical units
Nominal Money supply, prices, nominal interest rate Monetary units

3. Long Run vs. Short Run

The Classical Dichotomy

In the long run, the real and nominal sides of the economy are determined independently of each other. This separation is called the classical dichotomy.

Time Horizon Prices GDP Nominal/Real link
Long run (Classical Theory) Flexible Fixed at potential (supply-determined) Separate
Short run (Business Cycles) Sticky/rigid Flexible Joint determination
Why does this matter?

In the long run, government policy can't change real output — the economy always returns to its supply-determined potential Yˉ\bar{Y}. Demand-side policies (spending, tax cuts) just shift who gets the fixed pie and at what interest rate. This is the core insight of Chapter 3.


Supply Side: The Production Function

The Model

Y=F(K,L)\boxed{Y = F(K, L)}

where:

  • YY = total output (= GDP = national income in a closed economy)
  • KK = capital — tools, machines, structures used in production
  • LL = labour — the physical and mental effort of workers
  • FF = the production technology (the "recipe" turning inputs into output)

Key Assumptions

  1. Constant Returns to Scale (CRTS): F(zK,zL)=zYF(zK, zL) = zY for any z>0z > 0
    → Doubling all inputs exactly doubles output. This is a property of the technology, not an accident.

  2. Technology is fixed — we are in the short-to-medium run within the classical model.

  3. Inputs are fixed and exogenous at their normal, long-run employment levels:

K=Kˉ,L=LˉK = \bar{K}, \quad L = \bar{L}
Why are inputs fixed?

The classical model is a long-run equilibrium description. Over long time horizons, capital and labour converge to their normal utilisation rates. Transitory shocks don't change Kˉ\bar{K} or Lˉ\bar{L}. This is why output is supply-side determined.

Determining GDP

Because inputs are fixed and technology is fixed, output is pinned:

Y∗=F(Kˉ,Lˉ)\boxed{Y^* = F(\bar{K}, \bar{L})}

This is the key result of the classical model: GDP is supply-side determined, independent of demand-side policy.

Intuition

Think of the economy as a factory whose capacity is set by its machines and workers. You can shift around who buys the output, but you can't produce more just by wanting more.


Distribution of National Income

Factor Markets and the Profit-Maximising Firm

A competitive firm hires labour and rents capital to maximise profit:

max⁡K,L  P⋅F(K,L)−W⋅L−R⋅K\max_{K, L} \; P \cdot F(K, L) - W \cdot L - R \cdot K

Taking first-order conditions:

P⋅FL(K,L)=W  ⟹  MPL≡FL(K,L)=WPP \cdot F_L(K, L) = W \implies \text{MPL} \equiv F_L(K, L) = \frac{W}{P}
P⋅FK(K,L)=R  ⟹  MPK≡FK(K,L)=RPP \cdot F_K(K, L) = R \implies \text{MPK} \equiv F_K(K, L) = \frac{R}{P}
Factor prices in real terms

W/PW/P = real wage (the wage measured in units of output, not dollars)
R/PR/P = real rental price of capital

Each factor is hired up to the point where its marginal product (the extra output from one more unit) equals its real price. Beyond that point, the factor costs more than it adds.

Diminishing Marginal Returns

Both MPL and MPK are decreasing functions of the quantity of the factor:

  • Each additional worker adds less output than the previous one (because they share the same capital).
  • Each additional machine adds less output than the previous one (because fewer workers operate each machine).

This gives downward-sloping factor demand curves, and the equilibrium real wage/rent is pinned by Lˉ\bar{L} and Kˉ\bar{K}.

How is Total Output Distributed?

Using Euler's Theorem for homogeneous functions: if FF has CRTS, then:

Y=MPL⋅L+MPK⋅K\boxed{Y = \text{MPL} \cdot L + \text{MPK} \cdot K}

Dividing both sides by YY:

1=MPL⋅LY⏟labour’s share+MPK⋅KY⏟capital’s share1 = \underbrace{\frac{\text{MPL} \cdot L}{Y}}_{\text{labour's share}} + \underbrace{\frac{\text{MPK} \cdot K}{Y}}_{\text{capital's share}}

This is remarkable: under CRTS and competitive markets, all of output is exactly exhausted by paying factors their marginal products. There are no "leftovers."

The Cobb-Douglas Production Function

The most tractable specific form is:

Y=AKαL1−α,0<α<1\boxed{Y = A K^\alpha L^{1-\alpha}, \quad 0 < \alpha < 1}
Factor shares under Cobb-Douglas
  • Capital's share of total income = α\alpha
  • Labour's share of total income = 1−α1 - \alpha
  • In the U.S., labour's share ≈ 70%, implying α≈0.3\alpha \approx 0.3

To verify: MPL=(1−α)AKαL−α\text{MPL} = (1-\alpha) A K^\alpha L^{-\alpha}, so MPL⋅L=(1−α)Y\text{MPL} \cdot L = (1-\alpha)Y. ✓

Feature Formula
Output Y=AKαL1−αY = AK^\alpha L^{1-\alpha}
MPL (1−α)Y/L(1-\alpha) Y / L
MPK αY/K\alpha Y / K
Labour income (1−α)Y(1-\alpha)Y
Capital income αY\alpha Y
Returns to scale Constant (CRTS)

Demand Side: Components of Aggregate Demand

In a closed economy, all output must be used for one of three things:

Y=C+I+GY = C + I + G

Consumption: C=C(Y−T)C = C(Y - T)

Keynesian consumption function:

C=A+MPC⋅(Y−T)C = A + \text{MPC} \cdot (Y - T)
  • Y−TY - T = disposable income (income minus net taxes)
  • AA = autonomous consumption (spending from wealth, not current income)
  • MPC\text{MPC} = marginal propensity to consume = the fraction of each extra dollar of disposable income spent on consumption; 0<MPC<10 < \text{MPC} < 1
Why might C also depend on r?

In richer models, a higher real interest rate makes future consumption relatively cheaper (saving is rewarded). So CC may depend negatively on rr as well. The simple Keynesian model ignores this.

Investment: I=I(r)I = I(r)

I is a decreasing function of rI \text{ is a decreasing function of } r
  • rr = real interest rate = nominal interest rate − inflation
  • rr measures the real cost of borrowing (or opportunity cost of internal funds) to finance investment projects
  • Firms invest if the expected return on the project exceeds rr; higher rr kills marginal projects

Government Spending: GG

G=Gˉ,T=Tˉ(exogenous)G = \bar{G}, \quad T = \bar{T} \quad (\text{exogenous})
  • GG = direct government purchases of goods and services (excludes transfer payments like Social Security or unemployment benefits, which merely redistribute income)
  • Both GG and TT are set by policy — they are not model-determined

Equilibrium: The Loanable Funds Market

The Equilibrium Condition

Combining supply and demand:

Y⏟supply=C(Y−T)+I(r)+G⏟demand\underbrace{Y}_{\text{supply}} = \underbrace{C(Y-T) + I(r) + G}_{\text{demand}}

Rearranging:

Y−C(Y−T)−G⏟S=national saving=I(r)\underbrace{Y - C(Y-T) - G}_{S = \text{national saving}} = I(r)
S=I(r)\boxed{S = I(r)}

The real interest rate rr is the equilibrating price in the loanable funds market.

Types of Saving

Type Formula Description
Private saving Y−T−C(Y−T)Y - T - C(Y-T) Income not paid in taxes and not consumed
Public saving T−GT - G Tax revenue minus government spending
National saving SS (Y−T−C)+(T−G)=Y−C−G(Y - T - C) + (T - G) = Y - C - G Private + public
Why does S = I?

In a closed economy, there's no foreign lending. Every dollar saved domestically must be invested domestically. rr adjusts to make the two equal.

The Loanable Funds Diagram

  • Supply of loanable funds = national saving SS (vertical line if SS doesn't depend on rr; upward-sloping in richer models where higher rr encourages saving)
  • Demand for loanable funds = investment I(r)I(r) (downward-sloping in rr)
  • Equilibrium: intersection determines r∗r^* and I∗I^*
The special role of r

Because S=IS = I is exactly equivalent to Y=C+I+GY = C + I + G, the loanable funds market and the goods market clear simultaneously. You only need to think about one of them.


Comparative Statics: What Shifts S and I?

Shifts in the Saving Curve (leftward = lower S at every r)

Public saving (fiscal policy):

  • ↑ GG → ↓ SS (public saving falls)
  • ↓ TT → ↓ SS (private saving rises, but by less than the cut — MPC < 1 — so net effect is ↓ SS)

Private saving:

  • Changes in preferences (lower MPC → ↑ private saving)
  • Tax laws favouring saving (e.g., IRA accounts → ↑ disposable income)

Shifts in the Investment Curve (rightward = higher I at every r)

  • Technological innovations that require new capital
  • Tax laws favouring investment (e.g., investment tax credit)

Case Study: The Reagan Deficits (1980s)

Policy: Reagan increased defence spending (ΔG>0\Delta G > 0) and cut taxes (ΔT<0\Delta T < 0) simultaneously.

Effect on saving:

S=Y−C(Y−T)−GS = Y - C(Y-T) - G
ΔG>0  ⟹  ΔS<0(direct)\Delta G > 0 \implies \Delta S < 0 \quad \text{(direct)}
ΔT<0  ⟹  ΔC>0  ⟹  ΔS<0(indirect, via higher disposable income)\Delta T < 0 \implies \Delta C > 0 \implies \Delta S < 0 \quad \text{(indirect, via higher disposable income)}

Both policies reduce national saving. The saving curve shifts left.

Consequences in the loanable funds model:

  1. ↓ SS → saving curve shifts left
  2. r∗r^* rises (real interest rate increases)
  3. Higher r∗r^* reduces II — investment is crowded out
Crowding out

When government borrowing reduces the pool of saving, private investment falls. Reagan's deficits are a textbook example: the policies stimulated consumption but crowded out investment, with potentially adverse long-run effects on capital accumulation and growth.


Policy Exercises: Can Demand Policy Affect Output?

Policy Effect on SS Effect on rr Effect on II Effect on YY
↑ GG ↓ (public saving) ↑ ↓ (crowded out) Unchanged
↑ TT ↑ (public saving > ↓ private) ↓ ↑ Unchanged
Investment tax credit (↑ II demand, TT fixed) Unchanged ↑ ↑ in demand, but I∗I^* unchanged if SS is fixed Unchanged
Key conclusion: Demand policy is futile in the long run

In the classical model, Y∗=F(Kˉ,Lˉ)Y^* = F(\bar{K}, \bar{L}) regardless of demand. Government attempts to boost output through G or T changes merely reshuffle the composition of demand — they cannot increase total output. This is why the model is called supply-side determined.

This conclusion changes dramatically in the short run (where prices are sticky and output is demand-determined), which is why the classical model is not used for business-cycle analysis.


Summary

  1. Output is supply-determined: Y=F(Kˉ,Lˉ)Y = F(\bar{K}, \bar{L}) — technology and factor endowments pin GDP in the long run.
  2. Factors are paid their marginal products: Under CRTS + competition, MPL=W/P\text{MPL} = W/P and MPK=R/P\text{MPK} = R/P, and total output is fully distributed between labour and capital (Euler's theorem).
  3. Cobb-Douglas: Y=AKαL1−αY = AK^\alpha L^{1-\alpha} gives constant factor shares — capital earns α\alpha, labour earns 1−α1-\alpha.
  4. The loanable funds market equilibrates S and I: The real interest rate rr adjusts to equate national saving with investment; it simultaneously clears the goods market.
  5. Fiscal policy changes the composition of demand, not the level of output: Higher GG or lower TT reduces saving, raises rr, and crowds out private investment — real output is unchanged.