Week 5 · Alon Cohen

Inflation: Its Causes and Effects

Inflation: Its Causes and Effects

Part of: Macro-Economics II | Key concepts: Quantity Theory of Money, Velocity of Money, Money Neutrality, Fisher Effect, Classical Dichotomy, Nominal Interest Rate, Real Interest Rate, Money Demand


What This Chapter Is About

Chapter 5 answers the most fundamental macroeconomic question about money: why does inflation happen, and what does it do? The core insight is almost brutally simple — too much money chasing too few goods. More precisely, when the central bank grows the money supply faster than the economy grows, prices must rise. The chapter builds from a simple identity (the quantity equation) through money demand with interest rates, to the classical dichotomy: in the long run, money only affects nominal variables, not real ones.

Where Chapter 5 fits

Chapter 3 determined real output (Y) and the real interest rate (r) through the production function and loanable funds market. Chapter 4 explained money supply and the monetary system. Chapter 5 now explains what determines the price level P and inflation — closing the long-run classical model.


The Quantity Theory of Money

Velocity: Where It All Starts

Definition: Velocity of Money

Velocity (VV) is the rate at which money circulates — the number of times the average unit of currency changes hands in a given period.

If the economy's nominal GDP is $500bn but there is only $100bn in circulation, each dollar must change hands 5 times on average, so V=5V = 5.

More formally, we define velocity using nominal GDP (P×YP \times Y) as a proxy for total transactions:

V=P×YM\boxed{V = \frac{P \times Y}{M}}

where PP is the price level (GDP deflator), YY is real GDP, and MM is the money supply.

Why nominal GDP as the proxy?

Ideally we'd track every transaction in the economy, but that's unmeasurable. Nominal GDP (the value of final goods and services produced) is a reasonable proxy — it captures the size of the economy and thus the volume of "productive" transactions.

The Quantity Equation

Rearranging the definition of velocity gives us the quantity equation:

M×V=P×Y\boxed{M \times V = P \times Y}
This is an identity, not a theory

The quantity equation holds by definition — it's just a rearrangement of how we defined V. It becomes a theory (the Quantity Theory) only when we make assumptions about what is exogenous and what is constant.

From Identity to Theory: Making V Constant

The simplest money demand function (ignoring the interest rate for now) is:

(MP)d=kY\left(\frac{M}{P}\right)^d = kY

where kk is the fraction of nominal income people want to hold as money (exogenous). In equilibrium, M/P=kYM/P = kY, which gives M×(1/k)=P×YM \times (1/k) = P \times Y. Since 1/k=V1/k = V, this tells us:

  • If kk is exogenous → VV is exogenous and constant.
  • Empirically, U.S. M2 velocity has been fairly stable over the long run (though it drifts over decades).

With VV constant, the quantity equation pins down nominal GDP (P×YP \times Y) once the central bank sets MM.

Growth Rates: Turning the Equation into an Inflation Prediction

For any product of variables, growth rates add approximately (using the calculus approximation that cross-products of small changes are negligible):

ΔMM+ΔVV=ΔPP+ΔYY\frac{\Delta M}{M} + \frac{\Delta V}{V} = \frac{\Delta P}{P} + \frac{\Delta Y}{Y}

Since ΔV/V=0\Delta V / V = 0 (velocity constant), and denoting the inflation rate π≡ΔP/P\pi \equiv \Delta P / P:

π=ΔMM−ΔYY\boxed{\pi = \frac{\Delta M}{M} - \frac{\Delta Y}{Y}}
Intuition: the "excess money" formula

The economy needs some money growth just to finance real growth in output — that amount is ΔY/Y\Delta Y / Y. Any money growth above that is "excess" and translates directly into inflation. If the money supply grows 8% and real GDP grows 3%, inflation is 5%.

Money Neutrality

Definition: Money Neutrality

Money neutrality is the principle that changes in the money supply affect only nominal variables (prices, nominal wages, nominal GDP) and not real variables (real GDP, real wages, employment).

This follows directly from the quantity theory: when MM goes up, PP goes up proportionally, but YY (determined by K, L, and technology from Chapter 3) is unchanged.

Worked example — applying the quantity theory

Setup: VV is constant; ΔM/M=5%\Delta M/M = 5\% per year; ΔY/Y=2%\Delta Y/Y = 2\% per year; r=4%r = 4\%.

(a) Find π and i: π=5%−2%=3%\pi = 5\% - 2\% = 3\% i=r+π=4%+3%=7%i = r + \pi = 4\% + 3\% = 7\%

(b) Fed raises money growth by 2pp: π\pi rises by 2pp → ii rises by 2pp (Fisher effect, see below).

(c) Real growth falls to 1%: If Fed does nothing, π=5%−1%=4%\pi = 5\% - 1\% = 4\% (up 1pp). To keep π\pi constant at 3%, the Fed must reduce money growth by 1pp to 4%.

International Evidence

The cross-country data strongly support the quantity theory:

  • Countries with very high money growth (e.g. Belarus, DRC, Argentina) have very high inflation.
  • In the long run, a country's inflation trend closely tracks its money growth trend.
  • This is one of the most robust empirical regularities in macroeconomics.
Long-run vs. short-run

The quantity theory works well as a long-run theory. In the short run, velocity can shift and output can respond to money shocks — the classical model is not a good description of business cycles.


The Fisher Effect: Money, Interest Rates, and Inflation

Real vs. Nominal Interest Rates

When you earn interest on a deposit, you care not just about the number of dollars you receive (the nominal return) but about how much stuff you can buy with them (the real return). The two are linked by inflation:

r=i−π\boxed{r = i - \pi}

or equivalently (using expected inflation since the real rate must be agreed ex-ante):

i=r+Eπi = r + E\pi
Definition: Fisher Equation

The Fisher equation states that the nominal interest rate equals the real interest rate plus expected inflation.

Why Inflation Raises Nominal Rates One-for-One

From Chapter 3, the real interest rate rr is determined by the loanable funds market (savings and investment). Neither savings nor investment depend on nominal variables, so rr is pinned down in the real sector and is independent of money or inflation in the long run.

Therefore, if π\pi rises by 1pp, the only way the Fisher equation can remain in equilibrium is if ii also rises by 1pp. This is the Fisher effect.

Intuition

Lenders demand compensation for the erosion of purchasing power. If inflation is higher, they will only lend at a higher nominal rate. Borrowers are willing to pay the higher rate because they also benefit from repaying in devalued dollars. So both sides agree to incorporate expected inflation into the nominal rate, leaving the real rate unchanged.

Empirical support: Cross-country data show a near one-for-one relationship between inflation and nominal interest rates. The U.S. time series shows the same pattern with some deviation in the early 1980s — when Reagan's tax cuts and increased government spending reduced national saving, pushing rr up as well.


Money Demand with the Interest Rate

The Full Money Demand Function

The simple quantity theory assumed (M/P)d=kY(M/P)^d = kY — demand for real money balances depends only on income. But this ignores a crucial variable: the nominal interest rate ii.

Holding money means not holding interest-earning assets (bonds, deposits). The opportunity cost of holding money is the nominal interest rate ii. The higher ii, the less money people want to hold.

Definition: Money Demand Function

(MP)d=L(i,Y)\left(\frac{M}{P}\right)^d = L(i, Y) Money demand increases with income YY and decreases with the nominal interest rate ii. ("L" stands for liquidity, since money is the most liquid asset.)

By the Fisher effect, i=r+Eπi = r + E\pi, so money demand also depends negatively on expected inflation:

(MP)d=L(r+Eπ, Y)\left(\frac{M}{P}\right)^d = L(r + E\pi,\ Y)
Why expected, not actual, inflation?

People decide how much money to hold before they know what inflation will be. So it is the expectation of future inflation that determines the opportunity cost of holding money today.

Comparison: Simple vs. Full Money Demand

Feature Simple (Quantity Theory) Full Model
Variables (M/P)d=kY(M/P)^d = kY (M/P)d=L(i,Y)(M/P)^d = L(i, Y)
Effect of ii None (ignored) Negative
Effect of EπE\pi None (ignored) Negative (via Fisher)
When useful Long-run trends More complete picture

Money Market Equilibrium & Classical Dichotomy

Equilibrium Condition

Setting money supply equal to money demand:

MP=L(r+Eπ, Y)\frac{M}{P} = L(r + E\pi,\ Y)

This single equation, along with:

  • Y=F(K,L)Y = F(K, L) — production function determines real GDP
  • S=IS = I — loanable funds market determines rr
  • Central bank sets MM

…determines the price level PP.

The Classical Dichotomy

Variable Type Determined by
MM Nominal Central bank (exogenous)
rr Real Loanable funds market (S=IS = I)
YY Real Production function F(K,L)F(K, L)
PP Nominal Money market equilibrium: M/P=L(r+Eπ,Y)M/P = L(r + E\pi, Y)
ii Nominal Fisher equation: i=r+πi = r + \pi
Definition: Classical Dichotomy

The classical dichotomy is the separation of real and nominal variables in the classical model. Real variables (Y, r) are determined without any reference to money or prices; then the money market pins down all nominal variables (P, i).

This is the long-run justification for money neutrality: once real variables are determined by the real sector, all that money does is set the price level.

How P Responds to Changes in M and Eπ

Case 1: ΔM (money supply increases)

  • rr, YY, and EπE\pi are all unchanged (determined elsewhere).
  • The only way to restore M/P=L(r+Eπ,Y)M/P = L(r + E\pi, Y) is for PP to rise by the same proportion as MM.
  • Expected future price changes are unaffected → EπE\pi unchanged → ii unchanged.

Case 2: ΔEπ (expected inflation rises)

  • Even before MM changes, i=r+Eπi = r + E\pi rises.
  • Higher ii reduces money demand → people try to spend their money → PP rises now.
  • The price level adjusts immediately to changes in expectations about future money.
E.g., Fed announces it will increase M next year

Rational households update EπE\pi upward today. This raises ii today. Lower money demand at current MM and YY means there's an "excess supply" of money → people spend it → PP rises immediately, before M has even changed.

Common mistake: confusing levels and rates of change

The quantity theory says a one-time increase in MM causes a one-time increase in PP (same %). It does NOT cause a perpetual rise in inflation unless MM keeps growing faster than YY. Inflation is a sustained rate of change, not a price level shift.


Summary

Concept Key Result
Quantity equation MV=PYMV = PY — an identity, always true
Quantity theory VV constant → π=ΔM/M−ΔY/Y\pi = \Delta M/M - \Delta Y/Y
Money neutrality ΔM\Delta M affects only PP, not YY or rr
Fisher effect Δπ\Delta\pi → equal Δi\Delta i (one-for-one), rr unchanged
Money demand (M/P)d=L(i,Y)(M/P)^d = L(i, Y); falls with ii, rises with YY
Classical dichotomy Real sector determines real vars; money market pins nominal vars
P responds to EπE\pi Higher expected inflation → lower money demand → PP rises now
One-line summary

In the long run, the central bank controls inflation by controlling money growth; everything else (real GDP, real rates) is determined by the real economy and is unaffected by how much money is printed.