Week 3 · Yosi Ganel

Capital Accumulation, the Savings Identity & GNP vs GDP

Capital Accumulation, the Savings Identity & GNP vs GDP

Part of: Macro-Economics (Intro) | Key concepts: Savings Identity, Private Savings, Business Savings, Government Savings, Investment, Net Domestic Product, Net Income from Foreign Factors, Gross National Product


What This Recitation Covers

The big picture

Recitation 2 showed that output can be measured three equivalent ways. This recitation pushes further and asks: once the economy has produced its output, where does the saving come from, and how does it turn into investment? The answer is the capital-accumulation (savings) identity, which links the three sectors' savings to investment and the trade balance. The second half separates domestic from national product — the difference being payments to foreign factors of production (NIFF).

The two organising formulas of the whole recitation:

Sp+Sb+Sg=I+NX\boxed{S_p + S_b + S_g = I + NX}
GNP=GDP−NIFF\boxed{GNP = GDP - NIFF}

Every question is a variation on: build the sectors' savings from a P&L table, plug into the identity to back out the missing piece (usually investment), then convert between GDP and GNP when foreign factors appear.

The recitation also works the second two-firm problem (PS2 Q4 to Q6): value added per firm, output, GDP, consumption and government savings from profit and loss statements.


The Capital-Accumulation (Savings) Identity

Why it must hold

Start from the expenditure identity Y=C+I+G+NXY = C + I + G + NX. National income is either consumed, taxed, or saved, so it can also be decomposed from the income side. Setting the two decompositions equal and rearranging, total savings in the economy must equal investment plus net exports:

Sp+Sb+Sg=I+NXwhere NX=EX−IMS_p + S_b + S_g = I + NX \qquad\text{where } NX = EX - IM
Reading the identity

The left side is where funds come from — the savings of the three domestic sectors. The right side is where they go — into domestic capital (II) or into lending abroad (NXNX). A country that saves more than it invests (S>IS > I) must be running a trade surplus (lending the excess abroad); one that saves less runs a deficit (borrowing from abroad).

The three savings components, each computed differently:

Sector Savings formula Intuition
Private (SpS_p) Household net income − household taxes − consumption What households keep after spending and tax
Business (SbS_b) Firms' net (undistributed) profit Profit retained inside firms, not paid out as dividends
Government (SgS_g) Taxes − government spending Budget surplus (deficit if negative)
Business saving = retained earnings

SbS_b is only the profit firms did not distribute. Anything paid out as dividends or interest has already left the firm and become household income — it belongs in SpS_p, not SbS_b. Double-counting dividends is the classic slip.


Worked Problem — The Two-Firm Open Economy (PS2 Q1–Q2)

The data
  • Government collected 730 in taxes; paid 400 in public-sector wages and 200 on goods & services.
  • Household consumption 900; exports 300, imports 370.
  • Two firms report:
Firm Revenue Wages paid Payments to other firms Interest paid Taxes paid Dividends paid
A 1,600 800 400 30 100 60
B 1,100 600 300 20 80 40

Step 1 — Household income

Households receive wages (private + government), plus the interest and dividends firms pay out:

Private wages=800+600=1,400\text{Private wages} = 800 + 600 = 1{,}400
Government wages=400\text{Government wages} = 400
Interest + dividends=(30+20)+(60+40)=150\text{Interest + dividends} = (30 + 20) + (60 + 40) = 150
Household income=1,400+400+150=1,950\text{Household income} = 1{,}400 + 400 + 150 = \boxed{1{,}950}
Watch the slide's arithmetic

The lecture slide writes the interest+dividends total as 170 and household income as 1,970, but 30+20+60+40=15030+20+60+40 = 150, giving 1,950. The later steps correctly use 1,950, so treat 1,970 as a typo. Always re-add the factor payments yourself.

Step 2 — Private savings SpS_p

Households don't report their own tax directly, so infer it: total taxes collected minus the taxes the firms paid.

Household taxes=730−100−80=550\text{Household taxes} = 730 - 100 - 80 = 550
Sp=Household income−taxes−C=1,950−550−900=500S_p = \text{Household income} - \text{taxes} - C = 1{,}950 - 550 - 900 = \boxed{500}

Step 3 — Business savings SbS_b

Retained (undistributed) profit = revenue − wages − payments to others − interest − taxes − dividends:

SbA=1,600−800−400−30−100−60=210S_b^A = 1{,}600 - 800 - 400 - 30 - 100 - 60 = 210
SbB=1,100−600−300−20−80−40=60S_b^B = 1{,}100 - 600 - 300 - 20 - 80 - 40 = 60
Sb=210+60=270S_b = 210 + 60 = \boxed{270}

Step 4 — Government savings SgS_g

Gspending=400  (wages)+200  (purchases)=600G_{\text{spending}} = 400 \;(\text{wages}) + 200 \;(\text{purchases}) = 600
Sg=T−G=730−600=130S_g = T - G = 730 - 600 = \boxed{130}

Step 5 — Net exports and the identity → Investment

NX=EX−IM=300−370=−70NX = EX - IM = 300 - 370 = -70

Now plug into the savings identity and solve for II:

Sp+Sb+Sg=I+NXS_p + S_b + S_g = I + NX
500+270+130=I+(−70)500 + 270 + 130 = I + (-70)
900=I−70  ⇒  I=970(Q1 answer B)900 = I - 70 \;\Rightarrow\; \boxed{I = 970} \quad \textbf{(Q1 answer B)}
🗣️ In plain English

Add up what everyone saved (households 500, firms 270, government 130, so 900). That money has to go somewhere: some of it funds investment at home, and the economy is also running a trade deficit of 70 (so it is borrowing 70 from abroad). Saved funds of 900 plus the 70 borrowed means investment is 970.

Step 6 — Cross-check GDP three ways (Q2)

The identity is only trustworthy if GDP reconciles

Having found I=970I = 970, verify with all three GDP approaches — if they agree, the savings decomposition was correct.

Expenditure (uses):

GDP=C+G+I+EX−IM=900+600+970+300−370=2,400GDP = C + G + I + EX - IM = 900 + 600 + 970 + 300 - 370 = \boxed{2{,}400}

Income: wages + interest + taxes + net profit + dividends

=400+800+600+(30+20)+(100+80)+(210+60)+(60+40)=2,400= 400 + 800 + 600 + (30+20) + (100+80) + (210+60) + (60+40) = \boxed{2{,}400}

Value added: each firm's revenue − payments to other firms, plus government value added

A:1,600−400=1,200B:1,100−300=800Gov=400A: 1{,}600 - 400 = 1{,}200 \qquad B: 1{,}100 - 300 = 800 \qquad \text{Gov} = 400
GDP=1,200+800+400=2,400(Q2 answer C)GDP = 1{,}200 + 800 + 400 = \boxed{2{,}400} \quad \textbf{(Q2 answer C)}
All three agree at 2,400

Expenditure = Income = Value-added. This is the same reconciliation principle from Recitation 2, now used as a safety net on the harder savings problem.

🗣️ In plain English

GDP is one number seen from three sides: what is spent, what is earned, and what is added at each stage of production. All three give 2,400, so the numbers hang together.


Depreciation & Net Domestic Product (PS2 Q3)

Net Domestic Product (NDP) is GDP after subtracting the capital that wore out during the year:

Depreciation=GDP−NDP\boxed{\text{Depreciation} = GDP - NDP}
Q3

Given NDP=1,850NDP = 1{,}850 and GDP=2,400GDP = 2{,}400: Depreciation=2,400−1,850=550(answer B)\text{Depreciation} = 2{,}400 - 1{,}850 = \boxed{550} \quad \textbf{(answer B)}

🗣️ In plain English

Depreciation is the capital that wore out during the year. GDP counts it as if it were still there, NDP takes it off, so the gap between the two (550) is the wear and tear.

Gross vs. net must stay consistent

If you work with net output (NDP), investment must be net (Inet=Igross−depreciationI_{\text{net}} = I_{\text{gross}} - \text{depreciation}) too. Mixing a gross output figure with a net investment figure — or vice versa — is the single most common exam error, carried over from Recitation 2.


Worked Problem — Two Firms and a Government (PS2 Q4–Q6)

The data (profit and loss statements for 2000, in shekels)

There are two business companies and a government. Exports are 15 and imports 25, all carried out by the two firms. There was no investment in inventory, and gross fixed investment was 20 (Firm A) and 30 (Firm B).

Firm A Firm B
Sales (including overseas sales) 100 200
Payments for raw materials (including purchases from abroad) 30 70
Wages 20 50
Interest, rent and profit payments (dividends) 40 55
Depreciation 10 25
Net profit not distributed 0 0

Government budget:

Revenue Spending
Income tax on individuals: 180 Salary payments: 50
Purchases from companies: 90
Transfer payments: 10
No solution in source (Q4)

The slides are titled "Q4 and Q5" but no separate Q4 question text or answer appears in the source. The solution slides move directly to Q5 and Q6, so only those are answered below.

Q5 — Which statement is correct?

Options
  • A. Gross domestic product is equal to 340.
  • B. Net national income is 130.
  • C. Gross national product is equal to 250.
  • D. Gross national product is equal to 340.
  • E. Gross domestic product is equal to 300.

Step 1 — Value added of each firm

Value added = sales + inventory change − payments to other firms − depreciation (there is no inventory change here):

Firm A Firm B
+ Sales 100 200
+ Increase in inventory 0 0
− Payment to other firms −30 −70
− Depreciation −10 −25
Value added 60 105

Step 2 — Output (net of depreciation) in the economy

The government's value added is its salary bill (the purchases from firms are already inside the firms' output):

y=60+105⏟firms=165+50⏟government=215y = \underbrace{60 + 105}_{\text{firms}=165} + \underbrace{50}_{\text{government}} = \boxed{215}

With no information on payments to foreign factors or to local factors abroad, the slide assumes NIFF=0NIFF = 0.

Step 3 — Add back depreciation for GDP

GDP=y+depreciation=215+(10+25)=215+35=250GDP = y + \text{depreciation} = 215 + (10 + 25) = 215 + 35 = \boxed{250}

Since NIFF=0NIFF = 0, GNP=GDP−NIFF=250GNP = GDP - NIFF = 250. Q5 answer: C.

Why the others are wrong
  • A (GDP = 340) and E (GDP = 300): GDP is 250, not 340 or 300.
  • B (net national income = 130): net national income is y−NIFF=215y - NIFF = 215, not 130.
  • D (GNP = 340): GNP equals GDP here, which is 250.
🗣️ In plain English

Work out what each firm really adds (sales minus what it bought from other firms and minus wear and tear): 60 and 105. Add the government's 50 and you get 215 of net output. Put the wear and tear back (35) and GDP is 250. With no foreign income to worry about, GNP is the same 250.

Q6 — Further to the data of Question 5

Options
  • A. Private consumption is 70 and net investment of the economy is 15.
  • B. Private consumption is 70, government savings are minus 20.
  • C. Private consumption is 70 and government savings is minus 10.
  • D. Private consumption equals 50 and government savings equals 20.
  • E. Private consumption equals 70 and government savings equals 20.

Step 4 — Net investment

Inet=gross investment−depreciation=(20+30)−(10+25)=15I_{\text{net}} = \text{gross investment} - \text{depreciation} = (20 + 30) - (10 + 25) = \boxed{15}

Step 5 — Back out private consumption

Government purchases are G=50+90=140G = 50 + 90 = 140 (salaries plus purchases; transfers are not spending on output) and NX=15−25=−10NX = 15 - 25 = -10:

y=C+I+G+(EX−IM)y = C + I + G + (EX - IM)
215=C+15+140−10  ⇒  C=70215 = C + 15 + 140 - 10 \;\Rightarrow\; \boxed{C = 70}

Step 6 — Government savings

Net taxes are taxes minus transfer payments, and government savings are net taxes minus government spending:

Tn=T−transfer payments=180−10=170T_n = T - \text{transfer payments} = 180 - 10 = 170
Sg=Tn−G=170−140=30S_g = T_n - G = 170 - 140 = \boxed{30}

Q6 answer: A (consumption 70 and net investment 15).

Why the others are wrong
  • B and C: government savings are +30+30, not −20-20 or −10-10 (the government runs a surplus).
  • D: consumption is 70, not 50, and government savings are 30, not 20.
  • E: consumption of 70 is right, but government savings are 30, not 20.
🗣️ In plain English

Investment after wear and tear is 50−35=1550 - 35 = 15. Plug that, government spending of 140 and the trade deficit of 10 into y=C+I+G+NXy = C + I + G + NX and consumption has to be 70. The government collects 180 but hands 10 straight back as transfers, so it keeps 170 and spends 140, leaving 30 saved. Only option A matches.


National vs Domestic Product & NIFF

The second theme distinguishes where production happens from who owns the factors doing it.

Two different questions
  • Domestic product (GDP): value produced inside the borders, regardless of who owns the factors.
  • National product (GNP): value produced by the country's own factors, wherever they are located.

The bridge between them is NIFF — Net Income from Foreign Factors:

NIFF=income of foreign factors producing here⏟leaves the country−income of our factors producing abroad⏟comes inNIFF = \underbrace{\text{income of foreign factors producing here}}_{\text{leaves the country}} - \underbrace{\text{income of our factors producing abroad}}_{\text{comes in}}
GNP=GDP−NIFF\boxed{GNP = GDP - NIFF}
Sign intuition

NIFFNIFF is what leaks out to foreigners net of what flows in from our nationals abroad. If foreigners earn more here than our people earn abroad, NIFF>0NIFF > 0 and national product falls short of domestic product.

Ex. 3 Q1 — GDP > GNP implies what about NIFF?

GNP=GDP−NIFF  ⇒  GDP>GNP  ⟺  NIFF>0GNP = GDP - NIFF \;\Rightarrow\; GDP > GNP \iff NIFF > 0

So if GDP>GNPGDP > GNP, the net payment to foreign factors producing in the economy is positive — foreign-owned factors here earn more than domestic factors abroad. (answer C.)

🗣️ In plain English

If GDP is bigger than GNP, then foreigners working or owning things here earn more than our own people earn abroad. Money is leaking out, so NIFFNIFF is positive. It is about who gets the income, not about exports.

GDP > GNP is about factor payments, not trade

A tempting wrong answer links GDP>GNPGDP > GNP to exports vs imports. It does not — the wedge between domestic and national product is factor income (NIFF), a completely separate channel from the trade balance (NXNX).


Worked Problem — Ex. 3 Q2–Q4 (Adding Foreign Factors)

The data

Open economy, balanced government budget, export surplus 500. Government buys 1,000 of goods & services and pays 700 in wages+rent. All profit distributed, no inventory change, combined gross investment 3,000.

Firm A Firm B
Sales 10,000 9,000
Raw materials 1,000 2,000
Wages & rent 2,000 3,000
Depreciation 1,500 900
Dividends 5,500 3,100

Output (Q2)

Value added = Sales − payments to other firms − depreciation:

VAA=10,000−1,000−1,500=7,500\text{VA}_A = 10{,}000 - 1{,}000 - 1{,}500 = 7{,}500
VAB=9,000−2,000−900=6,100\text{VA}_B = 9{,}000 - 2{,}000 - 900 = 6{,}100

Government value added = its wages+rent = 700 (purchases are already inside the firms' output):

Y=7,500+6,100+700=14,300Y = 7{,}500 + 6{,}100 + 700 = \boxed{14{,}300}

Back out consumption (Q2 cont.)

Net investment = gross − depreciation:

Inet=3,000−(1,500+900)=600I_{\text{net}} = 3{,}000 - (1{,}500 + 900) = 600

With G=1,700G = 1{,}700 (purchases 1,000 + wages 700) and NX=+500NX = +500:

Y=C+I+G+NX  ⇒  14,300=C+600+1,700+500Y = C + I + G + NX \;\Rightarrow\; 14{,}300 = C + 600 + 1{,}700 + 500
C=11,500C = \boxed{11{,}500}
🗣️ In plain English

Add up each firm's value added (sales minus inputs minus wear and tear) plus the government's wage bill to get output of 14,300. Then everything else that output is spent on (investment, government, net exports) is subtracted, and what is left over, 11,500, must be consumption.

Savings & investment (Q3)

Using the identity in aggregate savings form, S=I+NXS = I + NX:

S=600+500=1,100(answer C)S = 600 + 500 = \boxed{1{,}100} \quad \textbf{(answer C)}
🗣️ In plain English

The economy's total saving is what it invests at home (600) plus what it lends abroad through the export surplus (500). That gives 1,100.

Net vs. "of the economy"

The question distinguishes net investment (I=600I = 600, capital added domestically) from net investment of the economy (S=1,100S = 1{,}100, total national saving including the 500 lent abroad via the export surplus). The export surplus is foreign investment by the country.

Foreign workers shift GNP but not GDP (Q4)

Suppose 1,000 of the wage bill is paid to foreign workers employed here.

GDP: unchanged  (production still happens inside the borders)GDP:\ \text{unchanged} \;(\text{production still happens inside the borders})
GNP=14,300−1,000=13,300  (1,000 accrues to foreign, not national, factors)GNP = 14{,}300 - 1{,}000 = 13{,}300 \;(\text{1,000 accrues to foreign, not national, factors})

Local (domestic) product stays the same; national product falls by 1,000. This is exactly NIFF=+1,000NIFF = +1{,}000 pushing GNPGNP below GDPGDP. (answer C.)

🗣️ In plain English

Foreign workers still produce inside our borders, so GDP does not change. But their pay goes to foreigners, not to our own factors, so GNP drops by 1,000.


The Standard Exam Recipe

Savings-identity questions in four steps

Step 1 — Sector savings. Build SpS_p (household income − household taxes − CC), SbS_b (undistributed profit), SgS_g (T−GT - G). Infer household taxes as total taxes − firms' taxes when not given directly. Step 2 — Net exports. NX=EX−IMNX = EX - IM (watch import vs export surplus wording). Step 3 — Apply the identity. Sp+Sb+Sg=I+NXS_p + S_b + S_g = I + NX; solve for the unknown (usually II). Step 4 — Reconcile. Cross-check with the three GDP approaches, and convert GDP↔GNP with GNP=GDP−NIFFGNP = GDP - NIFF whenever foreign factors appear.


Summary — Recitation 3 in Five Ideas

  1. Saving finances investment and lending abroad. The identity Sp+Sb+Sg=I+NXS_p + S_b + S_g = I + NX says total domestic saving equals domestic capital formation plus the trade balance.
  2. Three sectors, three savings rules. Private = income − taxes − consumption; business = undistributed profit; government = taxes − spending. Don't count dividends twice.
  3. NDP strips out depreciation. Depreciation=GDP−NDP\text{Depreciation} = GDP - NDP, and gross/net figures must never be mixed.
  4. Domestic ≠ national product. GNP=GDP−NIFFGNP = GDP - NIFF; the wedge is factor income to/from abroad, not the trade balance.
  5. GDP > GNP ⇔ NIFF > 0. Foreign factors earning here outweigh our factors earning abroad — production location and factor ownership are different questions.