Week 6 · Yosi Ganel

The Labor & Capital Markets, Factor Payments & Growth Accounting

The Labor & Capital Markets, Factor Payments & Growth Accounting

Part of: Macro-Economics (Intro) | Key concepts: Labor Market, Capital Market, Real Wage, Real Rental Rate, Factor Payments, Factor Income Shares, Growth Accounting, Cobb-Douglas Production Function


What This Recitation Covers

The big picture

Recitation 5 built the supply side of the classical model — the production function and its marginal products. This recitation puts those marginal products to work in markets. In the classical model of the long run, the two factors of production, labor and capital, are traded in competitive markets. The central result is that in equilibrium each factor is paid its marginal product, and — because the production function is Cobb-Douglas with constant returns to scale — this exactly exhausts total output and splits it into fixed income shares: labor gets (1−α)(1-\alpha) of GDP, capital gets α\alpha. The recitation closes with growth accounting (the Solow decomposition), which uses the same α\alpha weights to back out how much growth came from capital, labor, and technology.

The three results to carry into the exam:

WP=MPLRP=MPK(1−α)Y⏟to labor+αY⏟to capital=Y\boxed{\frac{W}{P} = MPL} \qquad \boxed{\frac{R}{P} = MPK} \qquad \boxed{\underbrace{(1-\alpha)Y}_{\text{to labor}} + \underbrace{\alpha Y}_{\text{to capital}} = Y}

Every multiple-choice question in this recitation is a comparative-statics exercise: shock one factor's quantity, then trace the effect through its marginal product (→ its real price), through the other factor's marginal product (→ complementarity), and through total output (→ the income split).


Production-Function Recap

The classical production side (from Rec 5) in one line, plus the two marginal products that drive the factor markets:

Y=A KαL1−α,0<α<1Y = A\,K^{\alpha}L^{1-\alpha}, \qquad 0<\alpha<1
MPL=(1−α) A(KL)αMPK=α A(LK)1−α\boxed{MPL = (1-\alpha)\,A\left(\tfrac{K}{L}\right)^{\alpha}} \qquad \boxed{MPK = \alpha\,A\left(\tfrac{L}{K}\right)^{1-\alpha}}
The one behavioural fact behind every question

Each marginal product falls in its own factor (diminishing returns) and rises in the other factor (capital and labor are complements). So: more workers ⇒ MPL↓MPL\downarrow but MPK↑MPK\uparrow; more capital ⇒ MPK↓MPK\downarrow but MPL↑MPL\uparrow. Memorise the two ratio formulas and you can sign every effect by inspection.


Nominal vs Real Wage

Wages are quoted in money (nominal), but what a worker actually cares about is how many goods the wage buys (real). If a single good is produced — say wheat at P=20P = 20 NIS/kg — and the monthly wage is W=4000W = 4000 NIS, then

Real wage=WP=400020=200 kg of wheat.\text{Real wage} = \frac{W}{P} = \frac{4000}{20} = 200 \text{ kg of wheat.}
Nominal wage=W,Real wage=WP\boxed{\text{Nominal wage} = W, \qquad \text{Real wage} = \frac{W}{P}}
Why the model works in real terms

Firms hire until the real cost of a worker equals the worker's real contribution to output (MPLMPL, measured in units of the good). Prices PP cancel out of the hiring decision, so the whole classical factor-market analysis is done in real (W/PW/P, R/PR/P) terms. The same logic gives the real rental rate R/PR/P for capital.


The Labor Market

Labor demand = the MPL curve

A competitive firm hires an extra worker whenever that worker adds more to output than they cost in real terms. It keeps hiring until W/P=MPLW/P = MPL. Because MPLMPL is decreasing in LL, the labor-demand curve slopes downward: at a lower real wage, firms are willing to employ more workers. LD:WP=MPL(K,L)\boxed{L^{D}: \quad \frac{W}{P} = MPL(K,L)}

Labor supply slopes upward — a higher real wage draws more people into work. Equilibrium sits where the downward LD=MPLL^D=MPL curve crosses the upward LSL^S curve, pinning down employment L0L_0 and the real wage (W/P)0(W/P)_0.

Reading the labor-market diagram

The total area under the demand (MPLMPL) curve up to L0L_0 is total output. The rectangle (W/P)0×L0(W/P)_0 \times L_0 is the wage bill paid to labor; the triangular area above the wage line but under the MPLMPL curve is what is left over for capital owners. This geometric split is the same fact as the algebraic income shares below.


The Capital Market

Capital is rented at a nominal rate RR; what matters is the real rental rate R/PR/P. By exactly the same logic as labor:

KD:RP=MPK(K,L)\boxed{K^{D}: \quad \frac{R}{P} = MPK(K,L)}

The demand curve for capital is the (downward-sloping) MPKMPK curve. The crucial difference is supply:

Capital supply is inelastic in the short run

The stock of capital (machines, buildings, a fixed number of fields) cannot change overnight. So capital supply is vertical — perfectly inelastic at the existing stock K0K_0. The real rental rate (R/P)0(R/P)_0 is then determined entirely by where the MPKMPK demand curve hits that vertical supply line. Total capital income=(RP)0×K0.\text{Total capital income} = \left(\tfrac{R}{P}\right)_0 \times K_0.

"Rent per unit" vs "total rent payments" are different things

A shock can push the rental rate R/PR/P up while total capital income αY\alpha Y falls (or vice-versa), because total income is rate × quantity × prices and depends on output. This distinction is the trap in Class Exercise Q2 below — don't equate a higher unit rent with higher total payments.


Factor Payments & Income Shares — The Key Derivation

The single most important algebraic result of the chapter: under Cobb-Douglas with CRS, each factor's total income is a fixed share of output.

Total payments to labor. In equilibrium the real wage equals MPLMPL, so the wage bill is employment times the real wage:

L⋅WP=L⋅MPL=L⋅(1−α)A(KL)α=(1−α) AKαL1−α=(1−α) YL \cdot \frac{W}{P} = L \cdot MPL = L \cdot (1-\alpha)A\left(\frac{K}{L}\right)^{\alpha} = (1-\alpha)\,A K^{\alpha}L^{1-\alpha} = (1-\alpha)\,Y
Labor income=(1−α) Y\boxed{\text{Labor income} = (1-\alpha)\,Y}

Total payments to capital. Symmetrically, capital income is the stock times the real rental rate:

K⋅RP=K⋅MPK=K⋅αA(LK)1−α=α AKαL1−α=α YK \cdot \frac{R}{P} = K \cdot MPK = K \cdot \alpha A\left(\frac{L}{K}\right)^{1-\alpha} = \alpha\,A K^{\alpha}L^{1-\alpha} = \alpha\,Y
Capital income=α Y\boxed{\text{Capital income} = \alpha\,Y}
Income exhaustion (Euler's theorem)

Adding the two: (1−α)Y+αY=Y(1-\alpha)Y + \alpha Y = Y. Paying each factor its marginal product uses up exactly the whole product — no more, no less. This is Euler's theorem for a CRS function, and it is why α\alpha is called capital's income share as well as its output elasticity. The shares are constant: they don't move when KK, LL, or AA change, only if α\alpha (the technology) changes.

The comparative-statics shortcut

Because total factor incomes are just αY\alpha Y and (1−α)Y(1-\alpha)Y, any shock that changes output by x%x\% changes both factor incomes by the same x%x\% — the shares stay fixed. So to sign a "total payments to labor/capital" question, you only need to sign the change in YY. This one line answers half the problems below.


Problem Set 5 — Solutions

Q1 — Which statement about Y=AKαL1−αY = A K^{\alpha}L^{1-\alpha} is correct?

Test each claim with the two tools — returns to scale (sum of exponents) and the marginal-product ratio formulas.

Claim Verdict Reason
A. α>0.5⇒\alpha>0.5 \Rightarrow increasing RS ✗ RS depends on α+(1−α)=1\alpha+(1-\alpha)=1, independent of α\alpha ⇒ always CRS
B. α<0.5⇒MPL\alpha<0.5 \Rightarrow MPL rises with LL ✗ MPL=(1−α)A(K/L)αMPL=(1-\alpha)A(K/L)^{\alpha} falls as LL rises
C. CRS for every 0<α<10<\alpha<1 ✓ Exponents sum to 1 ⇒ scaling inputs by tt scales output by t1t^1
D. α=0.2⇒MPK\alpha=0.2 \Rightarrow MPK falls as LL rises ✗ MPK=αA(L/K)1−αMPK=\alpha A(L/K)^{1-\alpha} rises with LL
E. α=0.8⇒MPK\alpha=0.8 \Rightarrow MPK rises as KK rises ✗ MPKMPK falls as KK rises (diminishing returns)
Answer: C — the production function is CRS for every 0<α<10<\alpha<1, because the exponents always sum to one.
🗣️ In plain English

The exponents add up to 1 whatever α\alpha is, so doubling all inputs always doubles output: constant returns to scale. The other options mix up returns to scale with how each marginal product reacts to its own factor and to the other factor.

Q2 — Real wage with Y=4K0.5L0.5Y = 4K^{0.5}L^{0.5}, K=100K=100, L=25L=25

The real wage equals MPLMPL in a competitive labor market:

WP=MPL=∂Y∂L=4⋅0.5 K0.5L−0.5=2(KL)0.5=2(10025)0.5=2⋅2=4\frac{W}{P} = MPL = \frac{\partial Y}{\partial L} = 4\cdot 0.5\,K^{0.5}L^{-0.5} = 2\left(\frac{K}{L}\right)^{0.5} = 2\left(\frac{100}{25}\right)^{0.5} = 2\cdot 2 = 4
Answer: A — the real wage is 44.
🗣️ In plain English

A firm pays a worker what that worker adds to output, the marginal product of labor. With 100 machines and 25 workers each worker has plenty of capital to use, so the real wage works out to 4 units of output.

Q3 — Capital share =12=\tfrac12; immigration raises LL by 4%

Here α=12\alpha = \tfrac12 (capital's share), and only labor changes. Sign each effect:

  • Output: Y1=AK0.5(1.04L)0.5=1.040.5Y≈1.02 YY_1 = A K^{0.5}(1.04L)^{0.5} = 1.04^{0.5}Y \approx 1.02\,Y ⇒ GDP up ~2% (so "grew 4%" is false).
  • MPK=αA(L/K)1−αMPK = \alpha A(L/K)^{1-\alpha}: L↑⇒MPK↑L\uparrow \Rightarrow MPK\uparrow (claim "declined 2%" false).
  • MPL=(1−α)A(K/L)αMPL = (1-\alpha)A(K/L)^{\alpha}: L↑⇒MPL↓L\uparrow \Rightarrow MPL\downarrow (claim "increased 2%" false).
  • Capital income =αY=\alpha Y: rises ~2% with output (claim "declined 2%" false).
  • Labor income =(1−α)Y=(1-\alpha)Y: rises ~2% with output. ✓
Answer: E — total payments to workers increased by about 2%.
🗣️ In plain English

More workers means more output, about 2% more here, and labor still gets its fixed share of it. So total pay to workers rises about 2%, even though each extra worker is a bit less productive.

Q4 — Capital share =14=\tfrac14; emigration cuts LL by 8%

Now α=14\alpha=\tfrac14, labor share =34=\tfrac34; labor falls.

  • MPKMPK: L↓⇒MPK↓L\downarrow \Rightarrow MPK\downarrow (claim "increased 6%" false).
  • MPLMPL: L↓⇒MPL↑L\downarrow \Rightarrow MPL\uparrow (claim "declined 2%" false).
  • Output: Y1=AK1/4(0.92L)3/4=0.920.75Y≈0.94 YY_1 = A K^{1/4}(0.92L)^{3/4} = 0.92^{0.75}Y \approx 0.94\,Y ⇒ GDP down ~6% (so "declined 2%" false).
  • Capital income =αY=\alpha Y: down ~6% (claim "declined 2%" false).
  • Labor income =(1−α)Y=(1-\alpha)Y: down ~6%. ✓
Answer: C — total payments to workers declined by about 6%.
🗣️ In plain English

Fewer workers means less output, about 6% less here, and labor still gets its fixed share of it. So total pay to workers falls about 6%, even though each remaining worker is more productive.

Q5 — What does the area under the capital-demand curve (left of KSK^S) represent?

The capital-demand curve is the MPKMPK curve. Integrating marginal product from 00 to K0K_0 recovers total output produced with that capital (given labor) — geometrically, the whole area under the marginal-product curve up to the employed quantity is total product, which then splits into the factor rectangles.

Answer: A — total GDP in the economy.
🗣️ In plain English

The marginal product curve shows what each extra unit of capital adds. Add up all those additions out to the capital actually used and you get the total output of the whole economy.

Q6 — α=13\alpha=\tfrac13; LL, KK, and AA each rise 3%

Scale everything by 3% simultaneously:

Y1=(1.03A)(1.03K)1/3(1.03L)2/3=1.03⋅1.031/3⋅1.032/3 Y=1.03⋅1.03 Y=1.032Y≈1.0609 YY_1 = (1.03A)(1.03K)^{1/3}(1.03L)^{2/3} = 1.03\cdot 1.03^{1/3}\cdot 1.03^{2/3}\,Y = 1.03\cdot 1.03\,Y = 1.03^2 Y \approx 1.0609\,Y

So GDP rises ≈ 6.1%. Output per worker meanwhile rises exactly 3% (the technology gain), since Y/L=1.0609Y/1.03L=1.03 (Y/L)Y/L = 1.0609Y/1.03L = 1.03\,(Y/L).

Answer (keyed): D — GDP increased by about 6%.
The slide's "A and B are not correct" is inconsistent

Option A says "GDP per worker increased by ~3%", and the arithmetic gives exactly that (+3%). So A is literally true as well — both A and D are correct statements. The slide keys D as the single answer but its remark that "A is not correct" is a slip. On the exam, read whether the question asks about GDP (→ D, ~6%) or GDP per worker (→ ~3%): the two are different quantities.

🗣️ In plain English

Raising all inputs by 3% gives 3% more from scale and another 3% from the better technology, so GDP rises about 6%. GDP per worker only gets the technology bit, 3%, so check which of the two the question asks about.


Class Exercises — Solutions

CE-Q1 — An increase in the capital supply

Capital supply shifts right; trace both markets.

  • Capital market: KSK^S shifts out ⇒\Rightarrow along the fixed MPKMPK demand curve, R/P↓R/P\downarrow; output (area under curve) ↑\uparrow.
  • Labor market: more capital raises MPLMPL (complements) ⇒\Rightarrow labor demand shifts out ⇒\Rightarrow W/P↑W/P\uparrow and L↑L\uparrow.

Algebraically: MPK=αA(L/K)1−αMPK=\alpha A(L/K)^{1-\alpha} falls as K↑K\uparrow, so R/P↓R/P\downarrow; MPL=(1−α)A(K/L)αMPL=(1-\alpha)A(K/L)^{\alpha} rises as K↑K\uparrow, so W/P↑W/P\uparrow; and Y↑Y\uparrow.

Answer: D — wages rise, rent per unit of capital falls, and GDP rises.
🗣️ In plain English

More capital means each machine adds less, so the rent per unit of capital falls. But each worker now has more equipment to use, so wages rise and total output goes up.

CE-Q2 — Earthquake destroys part of the capital stock (α=0.5\alpha=0.5, unit-elastic LSL^S)

Capital falls (people unharmed). This is the classic "rate up, total down" trap.

  • B. Wages rise? K↓⇒MPL↓⇒K\downarrow \Rightarrow MPL\downarrow \Rightarrow labor demand shifts in ⇒W/P↓\Rightarrow W/P\downarrow. ✗
  • C. Rents fall? K↓⇒MPK↑⇒R/P↑K\downarrow \Rightarrow MPK\uparrow \Rightarrow R/P\uparrow (rent per unit rises). ✗
  • D. Labor income unchanged? Both KK and LL fall ⇒Y↓⇒(1−α)Y↓\Rightarrow Y\downarrow \Rightarrow (1-\alpha)Y\downarrow. ✗
  • E. Capital's share rises above ½? The share is fixed at α\alpha by the (unchanged) technology. ✗
  • A. Total rent payments fall? Total capital income =αY=\alpha Y, and Y↓Y\downarrow, so total rent payments fall — even though the rate R/PR/P rose. ✓
Answer: A — total rent payments to capital declined (because output fell, even as the unit rental rate rose).
🗣️ In plain English

With fewer machines, each remaining one is worth more, so the rent per unit goes up. But total output falls, and capital gets a fixed share of a smaller pie, so total rent payments fall. A higher price does not mean higher total income.

CE-Q3 — Immigration expands worker supply by 5% (CRS)

  • A. MPKMPK unchanged? L↑⇒MPK↑L\uparrow \Rightarrow MPK\uparrow. ✗
  • B. MPLMPL rises? L↑⇒MPL↓L\uparrow \Rightarrow MPL\downarrow. ✗
  • C. Labor income falls? Y↑⇒(1−α)Y↑Y\uparrow \Rightarrow (1-\alpha)Y\uparrow. ✗
  • D. Capital income rises? αY↑\alpha Y\uparrow with output. ✓
  • E. If KK and AA also rise 5%, GDP rises exactly 5%? All of A,K,LA,K,L up 5% ⇒Y1=1.05⋅1.05α⋅1.051−αY=1.052Y≈+10.25%\Rightarrow Y_1 = 1.05\cdot 1.05^{\alpha}\cdot 1.05^{1-\alpha}Y = 1.05^2 Y \approx +10.25\% — more than 5%. ✗
Answer: D — total payments to capital will increase.
🗣️ In plain English

More workers means more output, and capital owners always get a fixed share of output. So total payments to capital rise. Extra workers also make each machine more productive, which pushes up its rent.

CE-Q4 — Capital share =13=\tfrac13; migration raises LL by 6% (CRS)

α=13\alpha=\tfrac13, labor share 23\tfrac23; only labor rises.

Y1=AK1/3(1.06L)2/3=1.062/3Y≈1.04 Y  ⇒  GDP up about 4%.Y_1 = A K^{1/3}(1.06L)^{2/3} = 1.06^{2/3}Y \approx 1.04\,Y \;\Rightarrow\; \text{GDP up about 4\%.}
  • A. GDP up ~4%? ✓
  • B. MPKMPK declines? L↑⇒MPK↑L\uparrow \Rightarrow MPK\uparrow. ✗
  • C. MPLMPL up ~4%? L↑⇒MPL↓L\uparrow \Rightarrow MPL\downarrow. ✗
  • D / E. Factor incomes up ~2%? Both αY\alpha Y and (1−α)Y(1-\alpha)Y rise ~4% (with output), not 2%. ✗
Answer: A — GDP increased by about 4%.
🗣️ In plain English

Only labor rises, and labor's exponent is 23\tfrac{2}{3}, so output grows by about two thirds of 6%, which is roughly 4%. Both factor incomes are fixed shares, so they rise about 4% too, not 2%.

CE-Q5 — Growth accounting for "Aspamia"

This introduces the growth-accounting (Solow) decomposition. Differentiating Y=AKαL1−αY=A K^{\alpha}L^{1-\alpha} in growth rates:

ΔYY=ΔAA+α ΔKK+(1−α) ΔLL\boxed{\frac{\Delta Y}{Y} = \frac{\Delta A}{A} + \alpha\,\frac{\Delta K}{K} + (1-\alpha)\,\frac{\Delta L}{L}}

Given labor share (1−α)=23(1-\alpha)=\tfrac23 (so α=13\alpha=\tfrac13), ΔLL=3%\dfrac{\Delta L}{L}=3\%, ΔKK=6%\dfrac{\Delta K}{K}=6\%, ΔYY=2%\dfrac{\Delta Y}{Y}=2\%, solve for the TFP (=total productivity) term:

0.02=ΔAA+13(0.06)+23(0.03)=ΔAA+0.02+0.02=ΔAA+0.040.02 = \frac{\Delta A}{A} + \tfrac13(0.06) + \tfrac23(0.03) = \frac{\Delta A}{A} + 0.02 + 0.02 = \frac{\Delta A}{A} + 0.04
⇒ΔAA=0.02−0.04=−0.02\Rightarrow \frac{\Delta A}{A} = 0.02 - 0.04 = -0.02
Answer: D — total productivity decreased by 2%. Output grew only 2% despite input growth of 3–6% because measured inputs "should" have delivered 4% growth; the missing 2% is a negative Solow residual.
🗣️ In plain English

Inputs alone should have delivered about 4% growth, but output only grew 2%. The missing 2% is the productivity (Solow residual) term, so technology and efficiency got worse by 2%.


The Standard Exam Recipe

Factor-market questions in five moves

1 — Real prices = marginal products. In competitive equilibrium W/P=MPLW/P = MPL and R/P=MPKR/P = MPK. Firms hire/rent each factor until its real price equals its marginal product. 2 — Sign the shocked factor's own price. A factor's marginal product falls in its own quantity, so more of a factor ⇒ lower real price for it. 3 — Sign the other factor via complementarity. More of one factor raises the other's marginal product (and real price). 4 — Income shares are fixed. Labor income =(1−α)Y=(1-\alpha)Y, capital income =αY=\alpha Y; they always move with output, and the shares only change if α\alpha changes. Sign YY to sign total factor payments. 5 — Growth accounting. ΔYY=ΔAA+αΔKK+(1−α)ΔLL\dfrac{\Delta Y}{Y}=\dfrac{\Delta A}{A}+\alpha\dfrac{\Delta K}{K}+(1-\alpha)\dfrac{\Delta L}{L} — solve for whichever term is unknown (usually the TFP residual).

The three classic traps

(i) Unit price up ≠ total income up — total income is a share of output, so it tracks YY, not the rate (CE-Q2). (ii) Single-input vs whole-economy scaling — one input up g%g\% raises output by only its exponent × g%g\%; all inputs up g%g\% raises output by (sum of exponents) × g%g\%. (iii) Per-worker vs total output — a technology gain raises GDP per worker; scaling all inputs raises total GDP by more (Q6).


Summary — Recitation 6 in Six Ideas

  1. Factors are paid their marginal products. Competitive equilibrium gives W/P=MPLW/P = MPL and R/P=MPKR/P = MPK; only real prices matter because PP cancels from the firm's decision.
  2. Labor demand is the MPL curve; labor supply slopes up. Their crossing sets employment and the real wage.
  3. Capital demand is the MPK curve; capital supply is vertical (inelastic) in the short run. The real rental rate is set where MPK meets the fixed stock.
  4. Income shares are constant. Labor earns (1−α)Y(1-\alpha)Y, capital earns αY\alpha Y, and the two exhaust output exactly (Euler's theorem). Total factor payments therefore move one-for-one with GDP.
  5. Capital and labor are complements. Adding one factor lowers its own marginal product but raises the other's — the engine behind every comparative-statics answer.
  6. Growth accounting splits growth into A, K, L. ΔYY=ΔAA+αΔKK+(1−α)ΔLL\tfrac{\Delta Y}{Y}=\tfrac{\Delta A}{A}+\alpha\tfrac{\Delta K}{K}+(1-\alpha)\tfrac{\Delta L}{L}; the TFP term is the residual left after inputs are accounted for.