Week 1 · Yosi Ganel

Nominal & Real GDP, Price Indices & GNP

Nominal & Real GDP, Price Indices & GNP

Part of: Macro-Economics (Intro) | Key concepts: Gross Domestic Product, Real GDP, Nominal GDP, Consumer Price Index, Producer Price Index, Inflation, Gross National Product


What This Recitation Covers

The big picture

Macroeconomics needs a single number for "how much did the economy produce?" You cannot add 80 tables to 100 t-shirts — they are different things. The solution is to value everything in money (NIS) and sum the values. But money values move for two reasons: quantities change and prices change. Separating those two forces is the entire point of this recitation.

The three tools introduced here — real vs nominal GDP, price indices (CPI/PPI), and GDP vs GNP — are the accounting backbone for everything else in the course (growth, inflation, business cycles).

Micro vs. Macro

Microeconomics studies individual agents — households, firms, single markets — and how they allocate scarce resources through supply, demand and prices. Macroeconomics studies the economy as a whole: aggregate output, inflation, unemployment, growth, and monetary/fiscal policy.

The forest and the trees

Micro zooms in on the trees (one market at a time); macro is concerned with the forest (the whole economy). Same economic system, different level of analysis.


Why We Need GDP At All

Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is the total market value of all final goods and services produced within a country's borders in a given period (usually a year or quarter).

The measurement problem it solves: suppose in one year a market produces 80 tables, 80 kg of apples, and 100 t-shirts. "Production" cannot be a sum of physical units — the units are incommensurable. So we compute the monetary value of each good (price×quantityprice \times quantity) and add the values, which are in common units (NIS).

GDP=∑ipi qi\text{GDP} = \sum_{i} p_i \, q_i
"Final" goods only

GDP counts final goods to avoid double-counting. The flour a bakery buys is an intermediate good; its value is already embedded in the price of the bread. Counting both would overstate output.


Nominal vs. Real GDP — The Core Distinction

The formula ∑piqi\sum p_i q_i hides a trap: the total moves when prices move even if quantities (real production) do not.

Definitions

Nominal GDP — output valued at current-year prices. Affected by both quantity changes and price changes.

Real GDP — output valued at constant (base-year) prices. Strips out price changes, so it reflects only changes in the quantity of goods produced.

Why nominal GDP alone is useless for judging the economy

If nominal GDP rises 10%, you cannot tell whether the country produced 10% more stuff or simply charged 10% higher prices for the same stuff. Only real GDP answers "are we actually producing more?"

Worked intuition (from the slides)

Year Tables (price × qty) T-shirts (price × qty) Nominal GDP
2015 1 × 100 2 × 50 200
2016 2 × 100 4 × 50 400

Nominal GDP doubled from 200 to 400 — but quantities never changed (still 100 tables, 50 t-shirts). Every prices doubled. Real production was flat; the whole "growth" was inflation.

Two equivalent ways to compute Real GDP

Method I — Deflate nominal GDP by the price-level change

Real GDP=Nominal GDPprice level change (deflator)\text{Real GDP} = \frac{\text{Nominal GDP}}{\text{price level change (deflator)}} 2016 example: prices doubled (factor 2), so Real GDP2016=4002=200\text{Real GDP}_{2016} = \dfrac{400}{2} = 200. ✅

Method II — Value current quantities at base-year prices

Choose 2015 as the base year. Re-price 2016's quantities using 2015 prices: Real GDP2016=(1×100)+(2×50)=200  (base-year 2015 prices)\text{Real GDP}_{2016} = (1 \times 100) + (2 \times 50) = 200 \;\text{(base-year 2015 prices)} Same answer — confirming both methods measure the same thing.

Real GDPt=∑ipibase qit\boxed{\text{Real GDP}_t = \sum_i p_i^{\text{base}} \, q_i^{t}}
Base year has no gap

In the base year itself, real GDP = nominal GDP by construction — you are valuing base-year quantities at base-year prices in both. Any divergence only opens up in other years. This single fact solves a lot of exam questions instantly.


Worked Example — Nominal & Real GDP with a Rate of Change

Data:

Product 2016 Price 2016 Qty 2017 Price 2017 Qty
Tables 50 100 150 150
Avocado 10 20 30 20

(a) Nominal GDP each year — current prices × current quantities:

Nom2016=50(100)+10(20)=5,000+200=5,200\text{Nom}_{2016} = 50(100) + 10(20) = 5{,}000 + 200 = 5{,}200
Nom2017=150(150)+30(20)=22,500+600=23,100\text{Nom}_{2017} = 150(150) + 30(20) = 22{,}500 + 600 = 23{,}100
🗣️ In plain English

Nominal GDP is just price times quantity added up for each year, so 2016 comes to 5,200 and 2017 jumps to 23,100. Most of that jump is prices going up, which is why we need the next step.

(b) Real GDP 2017 in 2016 prices — 2017 quantities valued at 2016 prices:

Real2017=50(150)+10(20)=7,500+200=7,700\text{Real}_{2017} = 50(150) + 10(20) = 7{,}500 + 200 = 7{,}700
Keep the two years straight

Take the quantities from 2017 and the prices from 2016: Tables 150×50150 \times 50 and Avocado 20×1020 \times 10. Swapping the price and quantity columns is the classic slip here. Always pin down explicitly: which year's quantities, which year's prices? Real GDP = current quantities, base prices.

🗣️ In plain English

Real GDP means this year's quantities at base-year prices, so 2017 comes to 7,700. Always ask yourself which year's quantities and which year's prices before you multiply.

(c) Rate of change in real GDP, 2016 → 2017. Use the general growth formula:

rate of change=NewOld−1\text{rate of change} = \frac{\text{New}}{\text{Old}} - 1

Since 2016 is the base year, Real2016=Nom2016=5,200\text{Real}_{2016} = \text{Nom}_{2016} = 5{,}200:

7,7005,200−1≈0.48⇒a 48% increase\frac{7{,}700}{5{,}200} - 1 \approx 0.48 \Rightarrow \text{a } 48\% \text{ increase}
🗣️ In plain English

Real GDP went from 5,200 to 7,700, which is about 48% growth, so real output rose by roughly half. Because 2016 is the base year, its real and nominal GDP are the same number, so you can use 5,200 straight away.

Reusable move

Whenever the base year appears in a "rate of change of real GDP" question, replace its real GDP with its nominal GDP — they are identical — and you avoid an extra calculation.


GDP per Capita — Growth vs. Population

Suppose real GDP rises 2% this year. Is the economy better off? Not necessarily — if the population grew faster, each person may have less. True living-standard growth is measured by real GDP per capita:

real GDP per capita=real GDPpopulation\text{real GDP per capita} = \frac{\text{real GDP}}{\text{population}}

Because it is a ratio, growth rates combine multiplicatively:

(1+gpercap)⏟per person×(1+gpop)⏟population=(1+gGDP)\underbrace{(1+g_{\text{percap}})}_{\text{per person}} \times \underbrace{(1+g_{\text{pop}})}_{\text{population}} = (1+g_{\text{GDP}})
Ex.1 Q1 — population shrinks

Real GDP per capita ↑ 3%; population ↓ 1%. Find real GDP growth. 1.03×0.99=1.0197≈1.02⇒+2% (answer b)1.03 \times 0.99 = 1.0197 \approx 1.02 \Rightarrow \textbf{+2\%}\ \text{(answer b)}

🗣️ In plain English

If people are per head 3% richer and there are 1% fewer of them, total output only grows about 2%. Growth rates multiply rather than add, which is why we get 1.03×0.99≈1.021.03 \times 0.99 \approx 1.02.

Ex.1 Q2 — population grows

Real GDP ↑ 5%; population ↑ 2%. Find per-capita growth. 1.051.02=1.0294≈1.03⇒+3% (answer c)\frac{1.05}{1.02} = 1.0294 \approx 1.03 \Rightarrow \textbf{+3\%}\ \text{(answer c)}

🗣️ In plain English

Output grew 5% but it is shared between 2% more people, so each person only gets about 3% more. You divide the growth factors: 1.05/1.02≈1.031.05 / 1.02 \approx 1.03.

Ex.1 Q3 — separating price from quantity over a decade

Nominal GDP ↑ 32%; price level ↑ 10%. Then real GDP: Real growth factor=1.321.10=1.20⇒real GDP +20% (answer d)\text{Real growth factor} = \frac{1.32}{1.10} = 1.20 \Rightarrow \textbf{real GDP +20\% (answer d)} Nominal-per-capita (if population flat) is just +32%, so option (b)'s "22%" is wrong.

🗣️ In plain English

Nominal GDP grew 32% but prices rose 10%, so only part of that is real output. Dividing out the price level leaves real GDP up 20%, because 1.32/1.10=1.201.32 / 1.10 = 1.20.

Ex.1 Q6 — average annual real growth

Nominal GDP: 500 bn (2011, base) → 625 bn (2013). Prices +2.5%/yr. Deflate 2013: Real2013=6251.0252=594.88\text{Real}_{2013} = \dfrac{625}{1.025^{2}} = 594.88. Total real change: 594.88500−1=0.1897\dfrac{594.88}{500} - 1 = 0.1897. Convert a 2-year total to an annual average using compounding: 1+0.1897=(1+x)2⇒x=1.1897−1≈0.0907=9.07%/yr (answer d)1 + 0.1897 = (1 + x)^2 \Rightarrow x = \sqrt{1.1897}-1 \approx 0.0907 = \textbf{9.07\%/yr (answer d)}

🗣️ In plain English

First strip out the inflation to get real GDP in 2013 (594.88), then work out the total real growth (about 19%) over the two years. Because growth compounds, you take the square root to get the yearly average of 9.07%, not just half of 19%.

Total vs. average growth

Never divide a multi-year total growth by the number of years. Growth compounds, so you take the tt-th root: 1+total=(1+avg)t1+\text{total} = (1+\text{avg})^t.


Price Indices — Measuring Inflation

A price index tracks the cost of a fixed basket of goods across time, so any change reflects prices only (quantities are held constant). There are two, distinguished by whose basket and which quantities they fix.

The two indices

Consumer Price Index (CPI) — cost of a base-year basket of consumer goods. Fixes base-year quantities (a Laspeyres-type index). Measures the cost of living.

Producer Price Index (PPI) — cost of the basket using current-year quantities of domestically produced goods (a Paasche-type index).

CPI worked example

Product 2015 Price 2015 Qty 2016 Price 2016 Qty
Chairs 5 10 6 15
Shirts 2 30 4 20

CPI holds base-year (2015) quantities {10, 30} fixed:

Basket2015 prices=5(10)+2(30)=110Basket2016 prices=6(10)+4(30)=180\text{Basket}_{2015\text{ prices}} = 5(10) + 2(30) = 110 \qquad \text{Basket}_{2016\text{ prices}} = 6(10) + 4(30) = 180
180110−1=0.63⇒prices rose 63%\frac{180}{110} - 1 = 0.63 \Rightarrow \textbf{prices rose 63\%}
🗣️ In plain English

The CPI asks: what would last year's shopping basket cost at today's prices? The same basket cost 110 in 2015 and 180 in 2016, so prices rose 63%.

PPI worked example

PPI holds current-year (2016) quantities {15, 20} fixed:

Basket2015 prices=5(15)+2(20)=115Basket2016 prices=6(15)+4(20)=170\text{Basket}_{2015\text{ prices}} = 5(15) + 2(20) = 115 \qquad \text{Basket}_{2016\text{ prices}} = 6(15) + 4(20) = 170
170115−1=0.48⇒prices rose 48%\frac{170}{115} - 1 = 0.48 \Rightarrow \textbf{prices rose 48\%}
🗣️ In plain English

The PPI does the same job but uses this year's output as the basket (15 chairs and 20 shirts). That basket cost 115 then and 170 now, so prices rose 48%, which differs from the CPI only because the weights differ.

Why CPI and PPI disagree

Same prices, different weights. CPI weights by what consumers bought in the base year; PPI weights by current production. The gap is not measurement error — it is the well-known Laspeyres-vs-Paasche divergence driven by substitution.

Which goods to exclude

Index Exclude Reason
CPI Investment goods (e.g. machines) Not consumed by households
PPI Imported goods (e.g. imported perfume) Not domestically produced
Ex.1 Q5 — computing a PPI change

Closed economy, no government. Food (consumer good) + machines (investment). 2000: 100 food @ $1, 30 machines @ $10. 2001: 110 food @ $1.10, 33 machines @ $13. PPI uses current (2001) quantities {110, 33}: 2001 basket at 2001 prices=110(1.10)+33(13)=121+429=550\text{2001 basket at 2001 prices} = 110(1.10) + 33(13) = 121 + 429 = 550 2001 basket at 2000 prices=110(1)+33(10)=110+330=440\text{2001 basket at 2000 prices} = 110(1) + 33(10) = 110 + 330 = 440 550440−1=0.25⇒PPI +25% (answer b)\frac{550}{440} - 1 = 0.25 \Rightarrow \textbf{PPI +25\% (answer b)}

🗣️ In plain English

The PPI uses 2001 quantities, so we price the same 110 food and 33 machines at 2000 prices (440) and at 2001 prices (550). The ratio gives +25%. Machines count because they are produced domestically, even though no household buys them.


From Index to Inflation Rate

An index is normalised to 100 in the base year. The inflation rate is the percentage change in the index between consecutive years.

CPIt=basket valuetbasket valuebase×100πt=CPIt−CPIt−1CPIt−1×100\text{CPI}_t = \frac{\text{basket value}_t}{\text{basket value}_{\text{base}}} \times 100 \qquad \pi_t = \frac{\text{CPI}_t - \text{CPI}_{t-1}}{\text{CPI}_{t-1}} \times 100
Practice — Guns & Butter (quantities fixed at 100 each)
Year Guns P Butter P Basket value CPI Inflation
2020 250 2.50 250(100)+2.5(100)=25,250250(100)+2.5(100)=25{,}250 100.00 —
2021 250 3.00 250(100)+3(100)=25,300250(100)+3(100)=25{,}300 100.19 0.19%
2022 275 3.50 275(100)+3.5(100)=27,850275(100)+3.5(100)=27{,}850 110.29 10.0%

2021 CPI: 25,30025,250×100=100.19\frac{25{,}300}{25{,}250}\times 100 = 100.19. 2022 CPI: 27,85025,250×100=110.29\frac{27{,}850}{25{,}250}\times 100 = 110.29. 2022 inflation: 110.29−100.19100.19×100=10.0%\frac{110.29 - 100.19}{100.19}\times 100 = 10.0\%.

🗣️ In plain English

The CPI is just the basket's cost divided by the base-year cost, times 100, so 2021 is 100.19 and 2022 is 110.29. Inflation is the change from last year's CPI, so 2022 is 10.0% and 2021 is only 0.19%.

Inflation is measured off last year's index, not the base

The 2022 inflation rate divides by the 2021 CPI (100.19), not by the base 100. The index is anchored to the base year; the inflation rate is always year-on-year.


GDP vs. GNP

The two aggregates differ on who does the producing vs. where.

Definitions

GDP — value of goods/services produced within a country's borders (territory-based), regardless of producer nationality.

Gross National Product (GNP) — value produced by a country's residents/nationals, wherever they are. Equals GDP plus net factor income from abroad (income residents earn overseas minus income foreigners earn domestically).

GNP=GDP+net factor income from abroad\boxed{\text{GNP} = \text{GDP} + \text{net factor income from abroad}}
Concept Basis Includes income earned…
GDP Location (borders) …inside the country, by anyone
GNP Nationality (residents) …by residents, anywhere in the world
Israeli worker in Japan

An Israeli resident works for a Japanese firm in Japan.

  • Counts in Israel's GNP (Israeli national) — not Israel's GDP (produced abroad).
  • Counts in Japan's GDP (produced on Japanese soil) — not Japan's GNP (not a Japanese national).
Ex.1 Q4 — definition check

"Zulu's GDP in 2014 is…" → (d) total value of goods and services produced within Zulu's territory during 2014. GDP is defined by borders, not by who consumes, who owns, or the government.

🗣️ In plain English

GDP is about where something is produced, not who owns it or who buys it. So Zulu's GDP is everything produced within Zulu's territory in 2014, which is answer (d).


Summary — Recitation 1 in Five Ideas

  1. You can't add apples to t-shirts — value everything in money and sum. That is GDP, ∑piqi\sum p_i q_i.
  2. Nominal moves for two reasons, real for one. Real GDP fixes prices at a base year, so it isolates quantity changes. Base year: nominal = real.
  3. Growth is per person and compounds. Real GDP per capita divides by population; multi-year growth uses the tt-th root, never simple division.
  4. Price indices fix quantities to isolate prices. CPI fixes base-year consumer quantities; PPI fixes current domestic-production quantities. Exclude investment goods from CPI, imports from PPI. Inflation = year-on-year % change in the index.
  5. GDP is territory, GNP is nationality. GNP=GDP+net income from abroad\text{GNP} = \text{GDP} + \text{net income from abroad}.