Week 5 · Dr. Yuval Reinfeld

Intellectual Property

Intellectual Property

Part of: Legal and Tax Aspects | Key concepts: Property Right, Intellectual Property Rights, Copyright, Patent, Trade Secret, Trademark, Design (IP), Novelty, Inventive Step, Distinctiveness, AI and Copyright

Why this lecture matters

For a founder, IP is usually the only real asset the company owns before it has revenue — the code, the brand, the invention, the secret recipe. Investors price a startup on the strength and defensibility of its IP. This lecture answers two practical questions: which of the five IP regimes protects my asset, and what do I have to do (register? keep secret? just create?) to actually hold that protection. Get the regime wrong and you either over-pay for protection you didn't need or — worse — disclose something that destroys the protection you could have had.


1. Foundation: What Is a Property Right?

Before IP makes sense you have to see that it is a species of property right, and inherit all the strength that property rights carry.

Definition — Property right

A property right is a legal right that grants a person direct control over an asset, tangible or intangible. It lets the holder use the asset, derive benefit from it, and protect it against harm caused by others.

Why property rights are the "strongest" rights

Three characteristics make property rights more powerful than ordinary (e.g. contractual) rights:

Characteristic What it means Why it matters
Strong & heightened protection One of the strongest rights in the legal system — protected more aggressively than contractual rights A court will defend it forcefully against intrusion
Attached to a specific asset The right binds the holder-to-asset link, not just relations with other people A landowner can enforce against any infringer, not only a person they contracted with
Enduring over time Generally independent of time or the identity of the holder Ownership of a house does not expire when the holder changes; it passes by inheritance

Types of property rights

  • Absolute rights — e.g. ownership of real estate (the fullest bundle of control).
  • Limited rights — e.g. a lease, lien, or tenancy right (a carved-out slice of control).
The key distinction: property right vs contractual right

This is the single most important framing in the lecture. A contractual right binds only the parties to the agreement (in personam). A property right is valid against the whole world (erga omnes / in rem).

Practical upshot for IP: once you hold a registered patent or trademark, you can stop anyone from infringing — you don't need to have a contract with them first. That "against everyone" quality is exactly why founders fight to convert know-how into registered IP rights.

Contractual right Property right
Binds Only the parties to the agreement Everyone — the whole world
Latin in personam in rem / erga omnes
Enforce against Your counterparty Any infringer
Example A supply agreement Ownership of land; a patent

2. Intellectual Property as a Modern Field

Property law is ancient — it has always regulated rights in tangible assets:

  • Movables (portable property: furniture, vehicles).
  • Real estate (immovable property: land, houses).

But property law sometimes reaches intangible assets too, and that is where IP lives.

Intellectual property — a young discipline

IP is only about 200 years old, began being taught in universities only in the 1980s, and developed mainly alongside information and computer technologies. It is a product of the modern era because the digital economy and innovation made intangible assets economically central.

The defining challenge — where is the boundary of the asset?

With a house, the boundary is obvious (the walls). With IP it is hard to define what counts as the protected asset — an abstract idea versus a concrete creation. IP law spends most of its energy drawing that line: ideas are not protected, but a particular expression, invention, or sign is. Founders get this wrong constantly ("someone stole my idea") — ideas alone are free; only the protectable form is owned.


3. The Five Fields of Intellectual Property

The map of IP

Everything in this lecture sits in one of five regimes:

  1. Copyright — creative works
  2. Patents — technological inventions
  3. Trade secrets — confidential commercial information
  4. Trademarks — brand-identifying signs
  5. Designs / industrial designs — visual appearance of products

The whole point of the lecture is to pick the right regime for a given asset. The master comparison:

Regime Protects Registration? Duration Core condition(s)
Copyright Creative expression (art, music, text, software) No — automatic on creation Long (life + decades) Originality / fixation in a work
Patent Technological inventions Yes — examined by Patent Authority 20 years from filing Novelty + non-triviality + inventive step + applicability
Trade secret Secret info with economic value No — kept confidential Potentially forever (while secret) Secrecy + economic value + reasonable efforts to keep secret
Trademark Brand signs (names, logos) Yes — Trademarks registry Renewable (effectively indefinite) Distinctiveness + not descriptive/misleading
Design Visual/aesthetic features of products Yes — Designs registry Limited period Novel, unique visual character
How to choose — the founder's decision tree
  • Is it code, content, or a creative work? → Copyright (you already have it, for free).
  • Is it a technical invention you can disclose and want a 20-year monopoly on? → Patent.
  • Is it a technical advantage you can keep hidden and would lose value if disclosed? → Trade secret (don't patent it — patenting publishes it).
  • Is it your brand / name / logo? → Trademark.
  • Is it the look of a physical product? → Design.

Definition — Copyright

Copyright is an old legal field protecting creators of works in the arts, culture, and software. Purposes: (1) give creators exclusive protection over their works; (2) encourage creativity by granting an economic incentive.

The economic logic is the recurring justification across all of IP: creation is costly and easily copied, so the law grants a temporary exclusive right to let the creator recoup investment — and thereby keeps the incentive to create alive.

Protected works

  • Literary works — e-books, blogs and digital posts (and a live question: content generated by AI?)
  • Musical works — TikTok creations, electronic music, video-game sound effects
  • Dramatic works — including augmented reality
  • Artistic works — digital works, NFTs
  • Modern additions — computer software, apps, UI/UX, computer games
Copyright is automatic — no registration needed

Unlike patents and trademarks, copyright protection arises the moment the work is created — no formal registration, no fee, no examination. This is why a startup's source code is copyright-protected from the first commit. (Registration exists in some countries as evidence, but it is not constitutive of the right.)


5. Patents

Definition — Patent

A patent protects inventors of technological innovations. Purposes: (1) encourage technological innovation; (2) provide a high economic return on the inventor's investment.

The patent is the classic IP bargain: the state grants a 20-year monopoly in exchange for the inventor publicly disclosing how the invention works (so society can build on it once the patent expires). Disclosure is the price of protection — which is exactly why some inventions are better kept as trade secrets.

Registering a patent in Israel — the three stages

Stage 1 — Preliminary examination (do it before you file)

Before submitting, check the invention against the Patents Law, 1967 requirements. The three substantive screens:

  • Novelty — is it new? Not previously published or known to the public.
  • Non-triviality / inventive step — does it go beyond the obvious? It must contain an inventive step.
  • Technological applicability — does it relate to a technological field with a practical application?

Search existing patents first in databases like the WIPO patent database or the Israeli patent database — a prior identical patent destroys novelty.

Stage 2 — File with the Patent Office

The application goes to the Israel Patent Authority at the Ministry of Justice and must contain:

  • Full description of the invention (including drawings if needed)
  • Claims — these define the scope of the protection requested (the most important part: they draw the legal boundary)
  • Abstract
  • Required fees

Patent examiners then check novelty, non-triviality and inventive step, and may demand clarifications and amendments from the inventor.

Stage 3 — Approval, registration & maintenance

If approved, the patent is entered in the patent register and protection runs for 20 years from the filing date. The inventor must keep paying maintenance fees to keep it alive.

Patents expire — and then competitors flood in

When a patent expires the technology becomes free to copy. Lecture examples:

  • Viagra — from 2013 many firms produced generics, causing a large price drop.
  • LCD screens.
  • Nespresso capsules.

For a founder this cuts both ways: your own moat has a 20-year clock, and expired patents are a legitimate opportunity to enter a market.

Characteristics of a patent — the trade-off

Patent
Protection period 20 years from filing
Conditions for grant Novelty, non-triviality, inventive step, technological applicability
Advantage Strong protection lets inventors recoup huge investments (e.g. developing COVID-19 vaccines)
Challenge Can stifle innovation — it locks others out of the technology for a long time
Intuition — the patent dilemma

The same feature that makes patents valuable to the holder (a 20-year exclusive lock) is what makes them socially costly (everyone else is locked out). IP policy is a permanent balancing act between rewarding the creator and keeping knowledge free — this tension reappears in every regime and again in the AI section.


6. Trade Secrets

Definition — Trade secret

A trade secret is protection over secret information with economic value that is kept confidential. Purposes / advantages:

  • Broader and simpler protection than a patent.
  • Preserves strategic information without a time limit.
  • Protection without any state examination.
  • May last forever — as long as the information stays secret.
The fragility of secrecy

The trade secret's strength is also its weakness: protection lasts only while the information remains secret. The moment it is disclosed — reverse-engineered, leaked, independently discovered — the protection evaporates, with no 20-year fallback like a patent. Classic example: the Coca-Cola formula, protected for over a century by secrecy rather than by a (long-expired) patent.

Patent vs trade secret — the founder's real choice

These two regimes are substitutes for the same kind of technical asset, and choosing between them is a genuine strategic decision:

Patent Trade secret
Requires disclosure? Yes — published to the world No — must stay hidden
State examination? Yes (costly, slow) None
Duration 20 years, then public Forever — until it leaks
Protects against independent discovery? Yes No — a rival who independently invents it is free
Best for Inventions that can be reverse-engineered anyway Advantages you can genuinely keep hidden (recipes, processes, algorithms)

7. Trademarks

Definition — Trademark

A trademark protects names and signs that identify goods and services. Purposes: (1) differentiation and unique branding of products/services; (2) incentivising investment in branding. In Israel, trademarks are governed by the Trademarks Ordinance [New Version], 1972, which protects symbols, words, logos and other identifying signs and stops competitors using them in ways that mislead the public.

What can be a trademark?

A trademark is a sign used to identify the goods/services of a particular trader, distinguishing them from another trader's. The sign may be:

  • Words, names, or letters
  • Numbers, logos, or graphic symbols
  • 3D shapes or combinations of these

Conditions for registration

The three registration tests
  1. Registrability — the sign must be unique and not directly descriptive of the product/service. It cannot be generic, misleading, or infringe existing rights.
    • ✗ "Orange Juice" for orange juice — descriptive.
    • ✗ "Bread" for a bakery, "Computer" for a computer store — generic.
  2. Distinctiveness — sufficiently distinguishable from other signs in the same field (e.g. iPhone, Starbucks).
  3. Actual use or intent to use — must show the sign is in use or genuinely intended to be used soon.

Rights granted on registration

  • Legal protection against unauthorised use.
  • Exclusivity over the sign within the registered goods/services class.
  • The ability to bring legal proceedings on infringement.
When a trademark will be refused
  • It misleads the public (e.g. "OrganicPure" on a non-organic product).
  • It is similar/identical to an existing registered mark in the same field (e.g. "Nikee" riding on Nike).
  • It includes official symbols, flags, or the state emblem.
  • It lacks distinctive character — i.e. it directly describes the product/service (e.g. "Leather Shoes" for a shoe brand).
Intuition — the "spectrum of distinctiveness"

Trademark law rewards signs that are arbitrary or invented (Apple for computers, Kodak) and refuses signs that are descriptive or generic ("Computer" for a computer shop). The further your brand sits from merely describing the product, the stronger and more registrable it is. Founders naming a company should lean distinctive, not descriptive.


8. Designs (Industrial Designs)

Definition — Design

A design protects industrial designs with unique visual features — the appearance of a product, not how it works. Purposes: (1) encourage innovative product design; (2) grant exclusivity for a limited period.

Designs in practice
  • The field was renewed by the new Designs Law.
  • Protected examples: chairs, jewellery, window profiles, wedding dresses.
  • Challenges:
    • Fashion-industry piracy is rampant — which paradoxically encourages rapid innovation (designers stay ahead by constantly producing new designs).
    • Despite the legislation, design registration is not widely used in practice.
Design vs patent vs copyright — don't confuse them

All three can touch a product, but on different layers:

  • Patent → how it works (function).
  • Design → how it looks (aesthetic form).
  • Copyright → an artistic work (which can overlap with a design for some creative objects). A smartphone can carry patents (the chip), a design (the casing shape), trademarks (the logo) and copyright (the OS code) simultaneously.

9. Intellectual Property in the AI Era

This is the lecture's frontier: AI breaks the assumption baked into every regime above — that a human creates the work or invention.

The three open challenges
  1. Ownership of AI-generated works — who owns an output the machine produced?
  2. Balancing the encouragement of innovation against the protection of traditional copyright (e.g. when models train on protected works).
  3. Using AI to monitor and enforce copyright at scale.

Key case law

How different jurisdictions are answering

China — the Beijing court recognised, for the first time, copyright in an AI-generated image. Decisive fact: the plaintiff supplied significant human input — tailored prompts and parameter coordination — to create the image. (Human creative contribution → protectable.)

United States

  • A machine cannot be a copyright owner; there is no automatic recognition of copyright in AI-generated works.
  • "Fair use" is assessed when protected works are used to train models.
  • Andersen v. Stability AI Ltd. — does using training data based on protected works infringe? Court emphasised the line between data analysis and direct creative use of copyrighted works.
  • The New York Times case — same training-data battleground.
  • Patents: Thaler v. Vidal — only a "natural person" can be an inventor, but the door is left open to patents created with AI in collaboration with humans.

European Union — focus on transparency about training data and a risk-management model.

Israel — no court ruling yet recognising copyright in AI-created content.

The pattern across jurisdictions

The emerging rule everywhere is the same: the more substantive the human creative contribution, the more likely protection attaches. Pure machine output (no meaningful human authorship) tends to fall outside copyright; meaningful human prompting/curation tends to bring it back in. This mirrors the foundational IP principle from §2 — the law protects a human creative act, not the raw existence of an output.


Summary

One-screen revision
  • IP is a property right, so it is strong, asset-attached, and enduring — and crucially valid against the whole world (in rem), not just between contracting parties (in personam).
  • Ideas are free; protected forms are owned. IP's hardest job is drawing the boundary between an unprotected abstract idea and a protectable invention/expression/sign.
  • Five regimes, pick the right one: Copyright (creative works/software, automatic, no registration), Patent (inventions, registered, 20 yrs, requires disclosure), Trade secret (confidential info, no registration, lasts forever while secret), Trademark (brand signs, registered, must be distinctive), Design (product appearance, registered, limited term).
  • Patent ↔ trade secret is a real strategic choice: patent = disclose + 20-yr monopoly + protection against independent invention; trade secret = stay hidden + potentially forever + no protection if a rival independently discovers it.
  • Patent test: novelty + non-triviality/inventive step + technological applicability; filed at the Israel Patent Authority (Patents Law 1967); claims define the scope; 20 yrs from filing; needs maintenance fees.
  • Trademark test: distinctive, not descriptive/generic/misleading; refused if it misleads, copies an existing mark, uses state emblems, or lacks distinctive character.
  • AI era: the consistent thread is human creative contribution — China recognised copyright where prompts/parameters were substantial; the US refuses machine inventors/owners (Thaler v. Vidal) and litigates training data as fair use (Andersen v. Stability AI, NYT); Israel has no ruling yet.

Concept stubs introduced/used here: Property Right, Movables, Real Estate, Absolute Rights, Limited Rights, Intellectual Property Rights, Copyright, Patent, Trade Secret, Trademark, Design (IP), Novelty, Inventive Step, Non-Triviality, Technological Applicability, Patent Claims, Israel Patent Authority, Patents Law 1967, Maintenance Fees, Distinctiveness, Trademarks Ordinance 1972, Designs Law, AI and Copyright, Fair Use, Andersen v Stability AI Case, Thaler v Vidal Case, New York Times AI Case